Rundgren Dismisses Swift as 'Apotheosis of Mediocrity' in Vulture Interview
Veteran producer Todd Rundgren has criticized Taylor Swift, calling her the 'apotheosis of mediocrity' and claiming she 'ruined music.' In a Vulture interview, Rundgren argued that the rise of female pop stars stems from the music industry pivoting to target young girls after male audiences shifted spending to video games in the 1990s. He dismissed Swift's vocal and songwriting abilities but praised Lady Gaga. The comments follow Swift's release of 'The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore' and her recent VMA award.
Key points
- Rundgren called Swift the 'apotheosis of mediocrity' and said she 'ruined music' in a Vulture interview.
- He argued that the rise of female pop stars is due to the music industry targeting young girls after men shifted spending to video games in the 1990s.
- Rundgren dismissed Swift's vocal and songwriting abilities but praised Lady Gaga as a 'real musician.'
- The comments follow Swift's release of 'The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore' and her recent VMA award.
- Swift has not responded to the criticism.
Background
Rundgren has previously criticized Swift on Rick Rubin's Broken Record podcast in 2022. The comments follow Swift's recent release of 'The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore' and her 33rd VMA award. Swift has previously addressed criticism of her music, stating that she respects people's subjective opinions on art.
How outlets are covering it
Variety, Billboard, and Pitchfork all reported on Rundgren's comments, but they emphasized different aspects. Variety focused on the 'ruined music' claim and the video game theory. Billboard highlighted Rundgren's dismissal of Swift's vocal and songwriting abilities and his praise for Lady Gaga. Pitchfork noted Rundgren's status as a 'rock curmudgeon' and the 'nonsensical' nature of his video game theory. All outlets reported that Swift has not responded to the criticism.
Why it matters
Rundgren's comments highlight ongoing debates about the quality and commercialization of modern pop music. His criticism of Swift, one of the most successful artists in the world, has sparked a broader discussion about the role of marketing and target demographics in the music industry. The comments also reflect the tension between traditional rock musicians and contemporary pop stars.
What to watch
Swift has not responded to the criticism. It is unclear if she will address the comments in the future. The comments may also spark a broader discussion about the quality and commercialization of modern pop music.
- Todd Rundgren Slams Taylor Swift, Says She ‘Ruined Music’ and Is ‘the Apotheosis of Mediocrity’ variety.com
- ‘She ruined music’: Legendary artist does not hold back on Taylor Swift yahoo.com
- Producer Todd Rundgren Criticizes Taylor Swift: ‘The Apotheosis of Mediocrity’ Billboard
- Todd Rundgren: Taylor Swift Ruined Music Pitchfork
- "She’s not a great singer. She’s not a great songwriter. She’s not a great dancer. To me, Taylor Swift is the apotheosis of mediocrity": Why don't you tell us what you really think about the world's biggest pop star, Todd Rundgren? MusicRadar
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on variety.com