Eagles Bench McKee, Turn to Joe Milton in Desperate Week 9 Bid

The Philadelphia Eagles are starting Joe Milton III in Week 9 against the New York Giants, replacing Tanner McKee after three consecutive losses. Milton, signed from the Dallas Cowboys practice squad in October, offers a more athletic, high-upside style compared to McKee's conservative approach. The move comes as the Eagles face a six-game losing streak and a season that appears effectively over, with head coach Nick Sirianni initially resisting the change before opting for a fresh offensive spark.
Key points
- Joe Milton III will start for the Eagles in Week 9 against the Giants, replacing Tanner McKee.
- McKee started three games for Philadelphia, losing all three, including a 27-10 loss to Washington where the team failed to sustain an early lead.
- Milton was signed from the Dallas Cowboys practice squad on October 16, one day before Jalen Hurts was placed on injured reserve due to blood clots.
- Milton has not played a regular-season game for the Eagles but has five career appearances, primarily as a reserve for the Patriots and Cowboys.
- The Eagles are now on their fourth quarterback of the season after Hurts, McKee, and the brief stint of Andy Dalton, who declined to return to Philadelphia.
Background
The Eagles' quarterback instability began in October when Jalen Hurts was placed on injured reserve due to a superficial blood clot. The team initially signed Joe Milton from the Dallas Cowboys practice squad while retaining Tanner McKee as the starter. Andy Dalton, who had been the backup, declined to return to Philadelphia and signed elsewhere. McKee started the first three games without Hurts, but the team lost all three, leading to a six-game losing streak. This move to Milton represents a shift from a conservative, experienced backup to a younger, more athletic option with higher risk and reward potential.
How outlets are covering it
NBC Sports and ESPN reported that Milton would start, noting that head coach Nick Sirianni initially indicated no change but subsequently reversed his decision. NFL.com emphasized the strategic shift, highlighting that Milton's ability to use his legs and hunt big plays could revitalize a stalled offense, contrasting with McKee's conservative style. CBS Sports noted that Milton is the team's third starting quarterback this season and highlighted his strong preseason performance in Dallas, where he completed 67.4% of his passes with a 118.2 passer rating. While all sources agree on the change, NFL.com and CBS Sports focus on the potential upside and athletic ability of Milton, whereas NBC Sports notes the uncertainty and the fact that Milton has not yet appeared in a game for the Eagles.
Why it matters
The decision to start Joe Milton signals a willingness to take a risk with a less experienced but more dynamic player in an attempt to stop a six-game losing streak. While the Eagles' season is likely over, the move could provide a glimpse of the offensive potential that was lacking under McKee. It also highlights the depth issues and instability at the quarterback position for Philadelphia, as they have cycled through four different quarterbacks this season. The outcome of this game may influence future roster decisions and the team's approach to the remainder of the season.
What to watch
The Eagles will face the New York Giants in Week 9, with Joe Milton starting at quarterback. The team will look to see if Milton's athleticism and arm strength can improve the offense's performance. The Giants, led by quarterback J.J. McCarthy, are the NFC East leaders, making this a significant matchup for both teams. The Eagles' performance in this game will likely determine their approach for the rest of the season, as they seek to find a consistent offensive identity.
- Report: Eagles to start Joe Milton at QB this week NBC Sports
- Sources: Slumping Eagles turn to Joe Milton as starting QB vs. Giants ESPN
- NFL Network: Eagles to start Joe Milton over Tanner McKee in Week 9 vs. Giants NFL.com
- Eagles to start Joe Milton at quarterback vs. Giants, replacing Tanner McKee CBS Sports
- Philadelphia Eagles: Make Interesting QB Decision for Week 9 Yahoo Sports
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on NBC Sports