Eags Bench McKee for Milton in Desperate Week 9 Bid

The Philadelphia Eagles have benched Tanner McKee in favor of Joe Milton for Sunday's game against the New York Giants. The move follows a 0-3 start for McKee and a six-game losing streak. Milton, signed from the Cowboys' practice squad on Oct. 16, will make his first NFL start despite limited experience. Teammates praise his arm strength and confidence, while the offense remains severely depleted by injuries.
Key points
- Eagles coach Nick Sirianni confirmed the quarterback change on Wednesday, reversing a statement made just two days prior where he insisted McKee would remain the starter.
- Joe Milton, a 26-year-old sixth-round pick from Tennessee, will make his first career NFL start on Sunday against the Giants.
- Milton was signed from the Dallas Cowboys' practice squad on Oct. 16 and was elevated to the backup role one week later.
- Tanner McKee has gone 0-3 in his three starts, contributing to a six-game losing streak for the Eagles.
- The Eagles' offense ranks last in the NFL in yards per game (265.3) and 30th in scoring (17.1 points per game).
- Key offensive players including wide receiver DeVonta Smith, running back Saquon Barkley, and tight end Dontayvion Wicks remain injured or limited.
Background
The Eagles have faced significant offensive turmoil this season. After Jalen Hurts was placed on indefinite leave due to blood clots, the team initially relied on Tanner McKee. In mid-October, they signed Joe Milton from the Cowboys' practice squad as a depth option. The offense has struggled with consistency, exacerbated by the retirement of right tackle Lane Johnson and the trade of interior lineman Cam Jurgens. New offensive coordinator Sean Mannion's scheme has not yielded the desired results, leading to a season that appears effectively over for the team.
How outlets are covering it
NBC Sports Philadelphia emphasizes the locker room's positive reaction to Milton, highlighting his arm strength and confidence as a morale booster. They note that players like Dallas Goedert and Darius Cooper were surprised by the speed of the decision but support the change. USA Today focuses on the statistical struggles of the offense and the abrupt nature of the change, noting that Sirianni had publicly defended McKee just two days earlier. ESPN's content was inaccessible due to a server error, so no perspective could be extracted from that source. The outlets agree on the facts of the change but differ in emphasis: NBC highlights the human element and team spirit, while USA Today highlights the statistical decline and coaching reversal.
Why it matters
This change represents a critical pivot for the Eagles' season. With a six-game losing streak and an offense ranked last in the NFL, the team is seeking a spark from a player with high upside but no starting experience. The outcome of this game will likely determine the trajectory of the season, as the Eagles face a bye week immediately after. The decision also highlights the depth issues and coaching challenges the team faces in the absence of their star quarterback.
What to watch
The Eagles will face the New York Giants on Sunday. If they win, they will have a bye week, providing a chance to regroup. If they lose, the season may be effectively over. The team will need to manage the transition for Milton, who has only thrown 53 passes in his NFL career. The offense will also need to navigate the absence of key players like DeVonta Smith and Saquon Barkley.
- Eagles locker room rallying around rocket-armed QB Joe Milton NBC Sports Philadelphia
- Sources: Slumping Eagles turn to Joe Milton as starting QB vs. Giants ESPN
- Eagles bench Jalen Hurts' replacement for QB they poached from Cowboys USA Today
- Giants shrug off big Eagles change: ‘Not a big deal’ Yahoo Sports
- Eagles turn to Joe Milton at QB, is Cole Payton next? | David Murphy Inquirer.com
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on NBC Sports Philadelphia