Hype Isn’t Destiny: Why The Witcher 3 Didn’t Click for Me

An Ars Technica personal essay argues that consensus and genre labels don’t reliably predict what you’ll enjoy. The author disliked The Witcher 3’s power-fantasy focus and fixed identity, preferring RPGs that let you grow from novice to master and craft a personal alter ego. The piece contrasts Witcher 3 with games like Cyberpunk 2077 and Mass Effect, notes the dangers of hype and influencer culture, and urges readers to know what they actually like rather than chasing what’s fashionable. It also touches on a craving for more varied, newer-game discussions and invites reader feedback, ending with a reminder that sale prices can still offer value for exploration.