Judge Dismisses Morgan Carey’s $20M Defamation Suit Against Mariah Over Memoir

Key points

• Justice Leslie A. Stroth of the New York State Supreme Court dismissed Morgan Carey’s remaining claims on Monday, ending a five-year lawsuit.
• Morgan had sued for over $20 million, alleging Mariah defamed him by calling him violent and accusing him of trafficking cocaine in her 2020 memoir, 'The Meaning of Mariah Carey.'
• The judge ruled that Morgan failed to establish 'actual malice,' a requirement under New York anti-SLAPP law, noting that ill will alone is insufficient to prove knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for the truth.
• Mariah’s lawyer, John Rosenberg, stated the singer is gratified that the court recognized the memoir addresses significant issues of public interest and affords broad protection to authors.
• Morgan’s attorney, Richard Altman, stated the family intends to appeal the decision soon, claiming it is inconsistent with prior rulings in the case.

Background

This ruling concludes a legal dispute that began in May 2021, shortly after the release of Mariah Carey’s 2020 memoir. The case focused on specific allegations regarding Morgan Carey’s behavior and reputation. Recent coverage of Mariah Carey has centered on her cultural influence, such as the 'Mariah Carey Night' theme on 'Dancing With the Stars' Season 35 in October 2026, but this court decision marks a significant legal milestone in her personal history.

Why it matters

The dismissal reinforces legal protections for authors and public figures in New York, establishing that memoirs addressing public interest are shielded from defamation suits unless the author acted with actual malice. It sets a precedent for how personal narratives involving family members are treated under anti-SLAPP laws.

What to watch

Morgan Carey’s legal team has indicated they will file an appeal against the dismissal. The outcome of the appeal will determine if the case returns to the courts or if the matter is finally closed.