Netflix's Lizzie Borden Drama Sparks Debate Over Historical Accuracy and Gendered Narratives

Netflix's new 'Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story' reimagines the 1892 Fall River murders, sparking debate over its portrayal of female rage versus historical facts. While the series emphasizes Lizzie Borden's psychological turmoil and relationship with her maid, critics argue it overlooks the class and gender biases that influenced her 1893 acquittal. CBS News revisited the crime scene to analyze forensic inconsistencies, noting that modern evidence would likely have led to a conviction.
Key points
- Netflix released 'Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story' on September 17, 2026, starring Ella Beatty as Lizzie and Rebecca Hall as stepmother Abby.
- The series depicts Lizzie's heavy menstrual cycles and a romantic relationship with maid Bridget Sullivan as primary motivations for the murders.
- CBS News investigators found the Borden house's thin walls make it unlikely Lizzie did not hear Abby's attack, and noted the absence of blood evidence on Lizzie's dress.
- The 1893 all-male jury acquitted Lizzie in under an hour, influenced by her affluent status and the lack of a recovered weapon.
- The show weaves in the case of Aileen Wuornos to draw parallels between historical and modern female violence.
Background
The Lizzie Borden case remains one of America's most famous unsolved crimes, with Lizzie acquitted in 1893 despite circumstantial evidence. The case has inspired numerous books, films, and the nursery rhyme 'Lizzie Borden took an ax.' Previous adaptations, including the 1975 TV movie and 2018 film 'Lizzie,' have explored various motives, from patriarchal oppression to mental illness. The current Netflix series is the fourth season of Ryan Murphy's 'Monster' anthology, following profiles of Jeffrey Dahmer and Ed Gein.
How outlets are covering it
The BBC highlights the series' focus on 'deep psychological drama' and 'female rage,' noting that creators Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan aim to address whether monsters are made or born. However, historian Cara Robertson criticizes the show for inventing a romantic relationship with the maid, pointing out that Lizzie never called Bridget by her real name. The Guardian offers a scathing review, describing the series as a 'borderline-fetishistic fever dream' that reduces complex historical issues to 'adolescent' obsessions with menstruation and violence, arguing it fails to address the societal prejudices that secured the acquittal. CBS News provides a forensic perspective, emphasizing that modern investigative techniques would likely have identified Lizzie as the killer due to the lack of blood evidence and the physical layout of the house, contrasting this with the 1893 jury's reliance on class and gender biases.
Why it matters
The release of 'Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story' reignites debate over how historical crimes are interpreted through modern lenses. It highlights the tension between dramatic storytelling and historical accuracy, particularly regarding the role of gender and class in the 1893 acquittal. The series serves as a cultural touchstone for discussions on female agency, violence, and the enduring mystery of one of America's most notorious unsolved cases.
What to watch
Viewers can watch 'Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story' on Netflix. The series is expected to generate further public discourse on the historical case, potentially influencing new academic or journalistic investigations into the 1892 murders. Future seasons of 'Monster' may continue to explore other infamous crimes, while the Lizzie Borden case remains a subject of ongoing cultural and historical analysis.
- I slept in the room where Lizzie Borden's stepmother was murdered. Here's what I discovered. CBS News
- Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story review – it’s like Ryan Murphy’s new series was written by adolescent boys theguardian.com
- 'A story of deep psychological drama': The notorious axe murders of Lizzie Borden's parents still haunt, 134 years on bbc.com
- Monster The Lizzie Borden Story Cast: Ella Beatty Stars in the New Season IMDb
- Ryan Murphy’s Bloody True-Crime Netflix Show Returns to Streaming Today Yahoo
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on CBS News