Gillis Claims He Promised SNL No Controversy Before Gym Attire Joke Sparked Backlash

3 min read
Source: HuffPost
Gillis Claims He Promised SNL No Controversy Before Gym Attire Joke Sparked Backlash
Photo: HuffPost
TL;DR

Shane Gillis addressed the backlash over his October 10 'Saturday Night Live' monologue on the 'Joe Rogan Experience,' claiming he assured producers the segment would not be controversial. He stated that SNL does not pre-approve host material, though critics argue the network bears responsibility for broadcasting the content. The incident reignited debates about misogyny in comedy, with Gillis acknowledging the cultural climate but maintaining that the public reaction was overblown.

Key points

  • Gillis stated on the 'Joe Rogan Experience' that he told SNL producers his monologue was a 'C-minus' but promised there would be 'no controversy.'
  • The comedian claimed SNL does not review or approve host monologues, asserting that only non-comedians receive written scripts from writers.
  • Gillis acknowledged the backlash was influenced by the current cultural climate but expressed surprise at the intensity of the public response.
  • The monologue included a joke about women dressing like 'whores' at the gym, which drew sharp criticism from former SNL cast members and other public figures.
  • Gillis noted he deleted his social media accounts immediately after the controversy, contrasting this with his 2019 firing, where he had maintained his online presence.

Background

Gillis was previously fired from SNL in 2019 after past podcast comments mocking Chinese accents and using anti-Asian slurs resurfaced. He has since hosted the show three times. Earlier coverage highlighted that SNL and NBC remained silent following the October 10 incident, while co-host Michael Che defended the joke as standard comedy, a stance that intensified criticism from peers like Dan Levy and Cecily Strong.

How outlets are covering it

Gillis and Joe Rogan argued that the backlash was overblown and that the joke was simply 'funny,' with Rogan stating that the current cultural climate makes people overly sensitive. Conversely, Dan Levy, former SNL cast member Ego Nwodim, and actress Inde Navarrette condemned the remarks as misogynistic. Levy specifically stated that men calling women 'whores' for wearing short shorts makes them misogynists, not the women themselves. Dana Carvey and comedian Jimmy Carr offered a more lenient view, with Carvey calling the incident a 'kerfuffle' over a joke and Carr arguing that intent matters more than content. People.com noted that a co-host on Rogan's show suggested SNL had approved the material because Gillis had performed it at the Comedy Cellar the week prior, a claim Gillis rejected.

Why it matters

The incident highlights ongoing tensions in the entertainment industry regarding editorial standards, the definition of acceptable comedy, and the responsibility of networks in moderating live content. It also reflects broader societal debates about misogyny and the impact of cultural climate on public discourse.

What to watch

Gillis is expected to continue his comedy career, including his upcoming projects, while the debate over SNL's editorial standards and the limits of comedy may continue to evolve. The network may face further scrutiny over its content moderation policies in the future.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on HuffPost