Critics Debate Whether 'You Can See Everything' Exposes Truth or Exploits Documentary Ethics

The documentary 'You Can See Everything' has become a box office phenomenon, grossing over $80 million, but faces intense scrutiny regarding its ethical boundaries. While praised for its intense observational access to Elizabeth Holmes before her prison sentence, critics argue its blend of staged reenactments and deceptive filmmaking techniques undermines the integrity of the documentary format.
Key points
- Directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, the film documents the final 34 days of Elizabeth Holmes before her 11-year prison sentence for fraud.
- The movie features a surprise second half starring Amanda Seyfried, who reprised her role as Holmes in unscripted reenactments without legal contracts or agent approval.
- The film has generated significant cultural debate, with some viewing it as a masterclass in observational cinema and others as a manipulation of truth that blurs the line between fiction and non-fiction.
- Holmes and her partner Billy Evans invited the cameras with the stated goal of launching 'Theranos 2.0' and redeeming Holmes's reputation through 'radical transparency.'
- The documentary’s release has sparked broader conversations about the ethics of modern documentary filmmaking in an era of deepfakes and postmodern media.
Background
Elizabeth Holmes, the former CEO of Theranos, was convicted of fraud related to the company's diagnostic technology. Her story was previously dramatized in the 2022 Hulu series 'The Dropout,' starring Amanda Seyfried, which has seen a resurgence in popularity since the release of this new documentary. The current film marks a significant shift in how true crime and biographical stories are presented, moving away from traditional investigative journalism toward a more experimental, performance-based format.
How outlets are covering it
The Hollywood Reporter’s Steven Zeitchik argues that the film is a 'sneaky' problem for the documentary form, suggesting that Fielder’s history of blurring fiction and reality casts a shadow over the authenticity of the footage. Zeitchik contends that the film may be furthering an anti-fact culture by making the audience complicit in deception. In contrast, the Australian Broadcasting Corporation praises the film as the 'most exquisite obsession of the year,' highlighting its ability to capture the ambiguous and maddening nature of Holmes’s personality. The ABC notes that while the film is 'discombobulating,' it successfully reveals the cultural shifts in Silicon Valley. The New York Times focuses on the logistical and dramatic aspects, noting the secrecy of the project and the shock of Seyfried’s involvement, while acknowledging the film’s status as a major cultural event. The outlets disagree on whether the film’s manipulative techniques are a betrayal of documentary ethics or a necessary reflection of contemporary reality.
Why it matters
The controversy surrounding 'You Can See Everything' highlights a growing tension in media consumption, where audiences are increasingly skeptical of all forms of truth. As the film challenges the boundaries of what constitutes a documentary, it forces viewers to question the reliability of visual evidence and the motivations behind the creation of media. This debate is particularly relevant in an era where deepfakes and AI-generated content are becoming more prevalent, making the distinction between real and fabricated content increasingly difficult to navigate.
What to watch
The film is expected to continue its box office run, with potential Oscar buzz for Amanda Seyfried’s performance. Further critical analysis and audience reactions are likely to emerge as the film’s release expands globally. The debate over its ethical implications may influence future documentary projects, potentially leading to stricter standards or new definitions of the genre. Additionally, the resurgence of interest in 'The Dropout' may drive further discussions about the accuracy of dramatized true crime narratives.
- You Can’t See Everything: The Sneaky Problem With the Elizabeth Holmes Documentary The Hollywood Reporter
- ‘Sit with the discomfort’: Examining the fact and fiction of ‘You Can See Everything’ YaleNews
- ‘You Can See Everything’ Puts ‘The Dropout’ on Trial The New York Times
- How Aristotle helps us unpack the art of deception in Nathan Fielder’s You Can See Everything The Conversation
- You Can See Everything is a surreal, brain-melting documentary ABC News & Headlines – Australian Broadcasting Corporation
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on The Hollywood Reporter