Stevie Nicks’ 1985 Studio Walkout Gave Tom Petty a Career-Defining Hit

3 min read
Source: Far Out Magazine
Stevie Nicks’ 1985 Studio Walkout Gave Tom Petty a Career-Defining Hit
Photo: Far Out Magazine
TL;DR

In 1985, Stevie Nicks abandoned the recording of 'Don't Come Around Here No More' after hearing Tom Petty’s vocal take, effectively gifting the song to Petty. The track, originally written by Dave Stewart for Nicks’ solo album 'Bella Donna,' became a major hit for Petty on 'Southern Accents' and has since been streamed over 60 million times.

Key points

  • Dave Stewart wrote 'Don't Come Around Here No More' for Stevie Nicks following a backstage meeting where he perceived her as vulnerable after her split from Joe Walsh.
  • Nicks intended to include the song on her 1985 solo debut, 'Bella Donna,' but became frustrated during the recording process.
  • Upon hearing Tom Petty’s vocal performance on the track, Nicks fired the production team and left the studio, telling Petty he could keep the song.
  • Petty included the track on his 1985 album 'Southern Accents,' where it became a significant commercial success.
  • The song has been heard over 60 million times, a figure cited by Far Out Magazine.

Background

This incident occurred during Nicks’ transition from Fleetwood Mac to a solo career, a period marked by creative tensions with band members like Lindsey Buckingham. While our archive notes recent 50th-anniversary tours by Stevie Wonder, it does not provide background on Nicks’ 1980s solo work. The 1985 event highlights the competitive nature of songwriting collaborations in rock music, where artists sometimes cede control of material to peers to resolve creative conflicts.

How outlets are covering it

Far Out Magazine emphasizes Nicks’ frustration with compromise in Fleetwood Mac, suggesting her solo work was a release from band dynamics, and notes that Petty’s version suited his voice better. American Songwriter highlights the tension between Nicks and producer Jimmy Iovine, noting that Stewart did not know Iovine, which may have contributed to the conflict. Both sources agree that Nicks described her reaction as 'selfish' and 'spoiled rotten,' but American Songwriter adds that Nicks may have felt she could not top Petty’s vocal performance. Far Out Magazine focuses on the long-term impact on Petty’s career, while American Songwriter details the lyrical inspiration stemming from Nicks’ perceived vulnerability.

Why it matters

The story illustrates how interpersonal dynamics and creative egos in the studio can alter the trajectory of major hits. It demonstrates that a song’s success is not solely dependent on its original writer or intended performer, but also on the circumstances of its recording and the decisions of the artists involved. The enduring popularity of the track, with over 60 million listens, underscores the lasting impact of these behind-the-scenes conflicts on music history.

What to watch

There are no immediate developments regarding this 1985 event, as it is a historical account. However, the continued streaming of the song and retrospective coverage in 2026 indicate ongoing interest in the legacy of 1980s rock collaborations. No new releases or tours related to this specific incident are reported in the sources.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on Far Out Magazine