Below: Critics Praise Hartnett's Performance but Debate the Six-Episode Structure

Key points

• The series, created by Jesse McKeown, is set in the fictional town of Snook's Arm in Newfoundland and stars Josh Hartnett as fisherman Calvin Penney.
• Critics have split opinions on the six-episode structure, with some finding it too long for the story while others appreciate the atmospheric buildup.
• Hartnett's Newfoundland accent was a point of contention, with some viewers finding it convincing and others noting it sounded 'too Irish' or difficult to follow without subtitles.
• The show blends creature horror with themes of climate change and community displacement, drawing comparisons to 'Widow's Bay' but receiving less critical acclaim for its writing.
• Creator Jesse McKeown and executive producer Jessica Rhoades have not confirmed plans for a second season, though the finale leaves several plot threads open.

Background

Our earlier coverage noted that 'Below' premiered on October 8, 2026, and was described as a thriller blending creature horror with family drama and climate themes. The series was noted for its generally positive reviews despite mixed opinions on its ecological messaging.

How outlets are covering it

Variety's interview with creator Jesse McKeown and executive producer Jessica Rhoades highlighted the deliberate choice to use a six-episode format to create an 'event' experience, with McKeown emphasizing the importance of the Newfoundland accent and the show's connection to local folklore. Rotten Tomatoes aggregated reviews that praised the series as a 'fresh addition to the creature horror genre' but noted that the limited runtime left the second half lacking, with some critics finding the pacing objectionable. Slate's review compared the show to 'Widow's Bay,' noting that while 'Below' is 'a lot of fun,' it is not as singular or confident in its writing, and that Hartnett's performance is more standard-issue than Matthew Rhys' in 'Widow's Bay.' The Hollywood Reporter's interview with Charlie Heaton focused on the actor's experience filming in Newfoundland and his subsequent role in the 'Peaky Blinders' sequel, but did not directly address the critical reception of the show's structure or accent.

Why it matters

The mixed reception of 'Below' highlights the ongoing debate in television about the optimal length for limited series, with some critics arguing that six episodes is too long for a creature horror story, while others appreciate the atmospheric buildup. The show's success also demonstrates the continued interest in Newfoundland as a filming location and the appeal of stories that blend horror with social and environmental themes.

What to watch

Netflix has not announced a renewal for 'Below,' but the open-ended finale and the strong performance of the cast may lead to a second season if the show performs well in viewership numbers. Charlie Heaton is set to lead the 'Peaky Blinders' sequel series, which may also impact the show's future if it is renewed.