Netflix’s 'Crew Girl' Premieres to Mixed Reviews, Teasing Season 2

2 min read
Source: The Hollywood Reporter
Netflix’s 'Crew Girl' Premieres to Mixed Reviews, Teasing Season 2
Photo: The Hollywood Reporter
TL;DR

Netflix’s new YA sports drama 'Crew Girl' debuted on September 10, 2026, following a teenage rower who joins a boys' team as coxswain. Critics were divided, with some praising its visual aesthetics and others criticizing its formulaic plot. The series ends with unresolved romantic tensions and a new rival, setting up a potential second season.

Key points

  • The series premiered on Netflix on September 10, 2026, created by Vivian Lin and Morwyn Brebner.
  • It stars Miku Martineau as Teagan, a rower who becomes coxswain for a boys' team at Easton Prep after moving to Massachusetts.
  • The show features a love triangle between Teagan, Josh, and Cam, alongside a rivalry with Britney Garner.
  • The season finale leaves Teagan’s future as coxswain uncertain due to a new girls' team and unresolved romantic subplots.
  • Josh is revealed to have a serious heart condition, complicating his future in the sport.

Background

Netflix has been aggressively expanding its YA drama slate, recently developing reality series and reviving teen-centric formats. 'Crew Girl' fits into this trend, aiming to capture the demographic with a sports-romance hybrid.

How outlets are covering it

The Hollywood Reporter’s Angie Han called the show 'good enough to binge' but criticized its underdeveloped characters and narrow focus on rowing. Variety’s Aramide Tinubu was harsher, stating the show 'capsizes and sinks' due to unrealistic dialogue and a lack of relevance to Gen Z. In contrast, the Los Angeles Times’s Robert Lloyd praised the show’s aesthetic and Canadian production style, noting its 'nice details' despite formulaic broad strokes. Deadline’s Dessi Gomez focused on the season finale, highlighting creator Vivian Lin’s comments on the unresolved love triangle and Josh’s health crisis as hooks for a potential Season 2.

Why it matters

The mixed reception highlights the ongoing challenge for streaming platforms in creating fresh YA content that resonates with current generations, while the season finale’s open-ended hooks suggest Netflix is banking on a second season to retain viewers.

What to watch

Netflix has not officially announced a Season 2, but the unresolved plotlines and creator comments suggest a renewal is likely. Viewers can expect to see if Teagan returns to rowing or stays as coxswain, and how Josh’s health condition affects his future.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on The Hollywood Reporter