FBI probes disappearance of 'Survivor' star and teen son after custody violation
The FBI is investigating the disappearance of former 'Survivor: China' contestant Jaime Dugan and her 16-year-old son, Harper Huffman, after she failed to return him to his father following a weekend visit on Aug. 30. A South Carolina judge has issued an arrest warrant for Dugan after she missed multiple court dates and refused to disclose their whereabouts. Harper's father, Erik Huffman, has sole custody and is actively searching for his son, expressing concern for his safety. The case stems from a contentious 2024 divorce, during which Dugan made unsubstantiated abuse allegations against Huffman that the court deemed unfounded.
Key points
- FBI has an open investigation into the whereabouts of Jaime Dugan and her son Harper, last seen in Cayce, SC, on Aug. 30.
- Spartanburg County Judge M. Todd Thigpen held Dugan in contempt and ordered her immediate arrest after she missed a Sept. 18 court appearance.
- Erik Huffman was awarded sole custody in 2024 after the court dismissed Dugan's allegations of physical and sexual abuse.
- Dugan previously faced a dropped cyberstalking charge in 2025 and filed for Chapter 13 bankruptcy with debts exceeding $509,000.
- Huffman is conducting a personal investigation across South Carolina to locate his son, stating he fears for Harper's safety.
Background
This case follows the 2024 divorce of Dugan and Huffman, who met on the 15th season of 'Survivor' in 2007. The couple married in 2009 and had Harper in 2010. The divorce trial lasted eight days, resulting in Huffman gaining custody and Dugan receiving every-other-weekend visits. The court order noted that Dugan had previously reported Huffman and his mother to law enforcement and social services for abuse, but refused to cooperate with investigators or make Harper available for interviews. The judge ruled these allegations unfounded and stated they did not justify defying custody orders.
How outlets are covering it
The New York Post and Daily Mail emphasize the legal consequences, highlighting the judge's contempt order and the FBI's involvement as a result of Dugan's refusal to comply with court mandates. FITSNews frames the story primarily as a missing persons case, focusing on the public safety concerns and the father's plea for his son's return. While the Post details the background of the divorce and the dropped cyberstalking charge, FITSNews provides minimal detail, focusing on the current status of the search. Both sources agree on the core facts: the son is missing, the mother is in contempt, and the father has sole custody. The Post provides more depth on the financial and legal history of the mother, including her bankruptcy filing, which FITSNews does not mention.
Why it matters
The case highlights the severe consequences of violating custody orders in high-profile divorces, particularly when minors are involved. The FBI's involvement indicates that the authorities view the situation as a potential safety risk for the child, not just a civil dispute. It also underscores the role of social media and public scrutiny in reality TV couples' post-show lives, as Dugan's status as an influencer and former contestant has drawn significant attention to the family's legal troubles.
What to watch
Law enforcement is expected to execute the arrest warrant for Dugan once her location is confirmed. The FBI investigation will likely determine whether the disappearance constitutes a criminal act or a civil custody violation. Huffman is expected to continue his personal search efforts while awaiting official updates from law enforcement. The court may issue further orders regarding the return of Harper and the surrender of his passport.
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on New York Post