Cornell DA admits missing key transcript in 2024 rape case as investigation reopens

Tompkins County District Attorney Matthew Van Houten admitted he never reviewed a 2024 transcript where the alleged victim stated she was '100% confident' she was raped, prompting a reopening of the criminal investigation. The transcript, obtained by CBS News, shows the victim described being incapacitated and coerced, contradicting the DA’s earlier decision not to charge. Van Houten plans to seek a grand jury review, while the victim’s attorney calls the initial inaction 'shocking.'
Key points
- DA Van Houten confirmed he had not seen the campus police transcript during his 2024 decision to decline charges, stating it was 'news to me.'
- The transcript reveals the victim, Jane Doe, told investigators she was 'completely and totally incapacitated' and that the assault involved coercion.
- Van Houten has reopened the criminal investigation and intends to present the case to a grand jury after reviewing the new evidence.
- Jane Doe’s attorney, Thomas Giuffra, criticized the DA’s initial failure to act, stating the office had a clear statement of rape and a group chat inviting assault.
- Cornell University’s Title IX investigation previously resulted in expulsions and suspensions, but criminal charges were not pursued until the recent reopening.
Background
This case stems from an alleged gang rape at Cornell University’s Chi Phi fraternity house on October 19-20, 2024. In 2024, the DA’s office declined to bring charges based on a signed statement from the victim, which described the initial encounter as consensual. The case gained renewed national attention in September 2026 after Jane Doe filed a civil lawsuit alleging she was drugged with ketamine and assaulted by seven students. New York Governor Kathy Hochul subsequently called for an independent review of Cornell’s response, while Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez condemned the university’s handling of the incident.
How outlets are covering it
CBS News New York highlighted the procedural gap, noting that Van Houten was unaware of the transcript where the victim explicitly stated she was raped. The New York Times focused on the role of the Cornell Daily Sun, which had pursued the story for two years and published the names of the accused, sparking national debate. The Washington Post emphasized the chilling nature of the fraternity group chat messages, specifically a 1:42 a.m. text asking if the 'shop' was still open. WHAM reported on the civil lawsuit naming Scott Norris of Canandaigua among the seven defendants, noting that attorneys for the defendants deny the allegations. Van Houten defended his 2024 decision by calling the victim’s later statements a 'legal conclusion' he had not been provided, while Giuffra argued the DA prioritized reputation over justice.
Why it matters
The admission by the DA that he missed critical evidence raises serious questions about the thoroughness of the initial investigation and the handling of sexual assault cases in New York. The reopening of the probe and the call for an independent review by the governor signal a potential shift in accountability for both the university and local law enforcement. The case also highlights the tension between civil lawsuits and criminal investigations, as well as the role of student journalism in bringing such cases to public attention.
What to watch
Van Houten plans to review the transcript and follow up with Cornell Police before presenting the case to a grand jury. The civil lawsuit seeks undisclosed damages from the seven students, the fraternity, Cornell University, and an Ithaca bar. An independent law firm has been hired to investigate Cornell’s response to the alleged assault, as requested by Governor Hochul.
- DA in Cornell University case says he never saw transcript of campus police interview with alleged rape victim CBS News
- Cornell student who made rape allegations said sexual encounters 'felt like coercion' in 2024 statement ABC News - Breaking News, Latest News and Videos
- Canandaigua man named in lawsuit over gang rape allegations at Cornell University 13wham.com
- Students at Cornell Daily Sun Pursued Sexual Assault Case for Two Years The New York Times
- Column | The three most chilling words in the Cornell rape case texts The Washington Post
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on CBS News