DNA Breakthrough Leads to Arrests in 2022 Citrus Heights Cold Case

3 min read
Source: KCRA
DNA Breakthrough Leads to Arrests in 2022 Citrus Heights Cold Case
Photo: KCRA
TL;DR

Placer County authorities arrested a mother and daughter in November 2026 for the 2022 murder of Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr. The victim’s severed head was found in Foresthill but remained unidentified until forensic genetic genealogy linked him to distant relatives. Investigators allege the daughter killed him at their Citrus Heights home while the wife helped dispose of the remains and collected his benefits.

Key points

  • Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., 73, was identified in January 2024 after his severed head was found in a trash bag in Foresthill in September 2022.
  • Forensic genetic genealogy at Othram Labs and FBI assistance identified distant relatives in Idaho, confirming the victim’s identity.
  • Mary Fitzmaurice, 45, was arrested on suspicion of murder, while her mother, Georgia 'Gwenn' Fitzmaurice, 75, was arrested as an accessory.
  • The women allegedly maintained a facade that Fitzmaurice was alive to continue receiving his Social Security and CalPERS pension benefits.
  • The rest of Fitzmaurice’s remains have not been located, and no motive has been confirmed by authorities.

Background

This case highlights the expanding use of forensic genetic genealogy in solving cold cases in California. Fitzmaurice, a former environmental scientist for the California Department of Public Health, retired in 2010. His death went unreported for four years because his wife and daughter told relatives he was a recluse suffering from substance abuse issues. The investigation gained momentum only after DNA testing linked the victim to out-of-state relatives, a method that has solved dozens of similar cases in the state.

How outlets are covering it

All four sources agree on the core facts: the discovery of the head in 2022, the 2024 identification via Othram Labs, and the November 2026 arrests. KCRA and the Sacramento Bee emphasize the financial motive, noting the women collected his $7,893 monthly pension. Fox News and People.com focus more on the 'facade' of his continued existence. Sheriff Wayne Woo declined to speculate on motive, stating investigative work is ongoing. The Sacramento Bee provides specific details on Fitzmaurice’s career and pension amount, while KCRA notes the Mosquito Fire was burning nearby when the head was found, though the discovery was away from the fire.

Why it matters

This case demonstrates the effectiveness of forensic genetic genealogy in identifying victims who were never reported missing. It also raises questions about the long-term concealment of a death and the financial fraud involved in collecting benefits for a deceased individual. The case remains active, with prosecutors evaluating additional charges related to the murder and benefit collection.

What to watch

The Fitzmaurices are scheduled for arraignment in Placer Superior Court on November 19, 2026. Prosecutors plan to file formal murder charges against Mary Fitzmaurice and are evaluating additional charges for Georgia Fitzmaurice related to the murder and benefit fraud. Investigators continue to search for the rest of Fitzmaurice’s remains and determine the exact location of the killing.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on KCRA