Judge Merryday allows core of Trump's $15 billion NYT libel suit to proceed

4 min read
Source: Politico
TL;DR

U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday has permitted the central claims of President Donald Trump’s $15 billion defamation lawsuit against The New York Times and publisher Penguin Random House to move forward. While the judge dismissed specific allegations regarding the 2024 book 'Lucky Loser' and articles by reporters Russ Buettner, Susanne Craig, and Peter Baker, he ruled that the publishers failed to adequately verify claims that Trump committed complex tax crimes. The case will now proceed to discovery and potential trial, with both sides maintaining their positions on the merits of the remaining claims.

Key points

  • Judge Merryday ruled that statements in the 2024 book 'Lucky Loser' suggesting Trump committed complex tax crimes were based on insufficient expert input, constituting a 'purposeful avoidance of the truth.'
  • The judge dismissed claims related to articles and book sections written by Buettner, Craig, and Baker, but allowed the core defamation claims against the publishers to proceed.
  • Trump’s amended 40-page complaint, filed in October 2025, removed references to the 2024 presidential election after an earlier 80-page version was rejected for lacking a concise summary.
  • The New York Times and Penguin Random House denied defaming Trump, calling the lawsuit 'meritless' and aimed at scoring political points.
  • Mediation talks failed, and a request by defendants to move the case to federal court in New York was denied, keeping the litigation in Tampa, Florida.

Background

This ruling follows a pattern of high-profile defamation lawsuits filed by President Trump against media organizations, including a $10 billion suit against the BBC that was allowed to proceed in November 2026. The current case stems from reporting on Trump’s business and financial dealings, specifically the 2024 book 'Lucky Loser' and subsequent articles. The legal battle highlights ongoing tensions between the administration and major news outlets, with Trump’s team framing the suit as a victory for 'honesty in America' and the defendants defending their right to publish investigative journalism.

How outlets are covering it

Politico and The Guardian report the ruling as a partial victory for Trump, noting the dismissal of claims against individual reporters but the allowance of core claims against the publishers. Deadline emphasizes the judge’s critical language regarding the publishers' failure to seek expert opinions, framing the decision as a significant win for the president's legal campaign against media companies. The New York Times and Penguin Random House, through their representatives, maintain that the remaining claims are legally flawed and meritless, while Trump’s spokesperson described the ruling as a victory for 'honesty in America' and a step toward holding 'fake news' accountable. The sources agree on the procedural outcome but differ in tone, with Deadline using more colorful language and The Guardian focusing on the legal implications for press freedom.

Why it matters

The decision sets a precedent for how courts evaluate the standard of care in publishing allegations of criminal conduct, particularly when expert verification is absent. It may influence future defamation cases involving public figures and media outlets, potentially chilling investigative journalism if publishers are found liable for failing to seek expert opinions on complex financial or tax matters. The case also underscores the ongoing legal battles between the Trump administration and major media organizations, with potential implications for press freedom and the role of the judiciary in mediating such disputes.

What to watch

The case will proceed to discovery, with both sides preparing for potential trial. The outcome may not be determined before Trump leaves office in 2029, but the ruling could influence the trajectory of similar lawsuits and the legal strategies of media organizations in reporting on public figures. The New York Times and Penguin Random House will continue to defend their position, arguing that the remaining claims lack legal merit, while Trump’s team will likely leverage the ruling in its broader campaign against media critics.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on Politico