DOJ Abandons Alaska Election Lawsuit After Peltola Secures Majority

4 min read
Source: The Washington Post
DOJ Abandons Alaska Election Lawsuit After Peltola Secures Majority
Photo: The Washington Post
TL;DR

The U.S. Department of Justice has withdrawn its appeal in a lawsuit that sought to delay the certification of Alaska’s U.S. Senate election. The move follows Democratic candidate Mary Peltola’s victory, which secured an outright majority of votes, rendering the federal government’s investigation into potential voter confusion moot. The Justice Department argued that once ballots were counted, it was impossible to determine if voters intended to support incumbent Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan or the unaffiliated candidate Dan J. Sullivan. This decision concludes a legal battle that began in October, shortly after President Trump publicly encouraged the administration to challenge the ballot design. The withdrawal ensures the state can proceed with certifying Peltola’s win without federal interference, a process that had previously been blocked by a district court judge who ruled the government lacked standing to segregate ballots.

Key points

  • The Justice Department asked the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to dismiss its lawsuit, citing the mootness of the case after Peltola won with a majority of votes.
  • Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward stated that the government could no longer examine whether votes cast for Dan J. Sullivan were intended for the incumbent, as the ballots had already been counted.
  • Peltola’s victory gives Democrats a 56-44 majority in the Senate, their largest advantage in 16 years and their biggest midterm gain in nearly 70 years.
  • The lawsuit was filed in October following President Trump’s claims that the inclusion of Dan J. Sullivan on the ballot was a stunt to defraud voters.
  • A federal judge in Alaska had previously rejected the DOJ’s bid to delay certification, ruling that segregating ballots would violate voter secrecy and that the government lacked standing.

Background

This development follows a series of legal challenges to the Alaska Senate race. In early November, U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the DOJ’s initial request to block certification, finding that the federal government could not investigate voter intent or segregate ballots without violating state sovereignty and voter secrecy. Prior to that ruling, voting experts and former election officials had submitted amicus briefs urging the Ninth Circuit to dismiss the case, arguing that the state’s ranked-choice voting system and clear ballot labeling mitigated any potential confusion between the two Sullivan candidates. The current withdrawal by the DOJ marks the final step in this legal dispute, allowing the state to finalize the results of a race that was critical for determining control of the U.S. Senate.

How outlets are covering it

The Washington Post highlights the DOJ’s admission that the investigation is no longer feasible after the ballots were counted, framing the withdrawal as a concession to the reality of the vote totals. NBC News emphasizes the political context, noting that President Trump had personally encouraged the lawsuit and that the DOJ’s filing described the withdrawal as a reluctant acknowledgment of the situation. AP News focuses on the broader implications of Peltola’s victory, contextualizing it within the Democrats’ historic midterm gains, including flipping nine Senate seats and reclaiming the House. While all sources agree on the outcome, the Post and NBC focus on the legal mechanics and the administration’s role, whereas AP places the event within the larger narrative of the 2026 midterm elections.

Why it matters

The withdrawal of the DOJ’s appeal removes the last federal legal obstacle to certifying the Alaska Senate race, solidifying the Democrats’ control of the Senate. This outcome underscores the limits of federal intervention in state election processes, particularly when the results are clear and the legal basis for challenging them is weak. It also highlights the political fallout of the 2026 midterms, where the president’s party suffered significant losses, and the administration’s attempts to influence election outcomes through legal means have been largely unsuccessful. The case serves as a precedent for the boundaries of federal authority in state elections and the importance of voter secrecy and ballot integrity.

What to watch

The state of Alaska is expected to proceed with the certification of the Senate race results, officially confirming Mary Peltola as the winner. With the legal challenges resolved, attention will shift to the broader implications of the midterm elections, including the Democrats’ new majority in the Senate and the House. The Justice Department may face scrutiny over its handling of the case, particularly given the public statements by President Trump encouraging the lawsuit. Future legal challenges to election results may be less likely to succeed, given the precedent set by the district court’s ruling and the DOJ’s withdrawal of the appeal.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on The Washington Post