James Copenhaver, 2024 Butler rally shooting survivor, dies at 76

Key points

• James Copenhaver died on Wednesday at West Penn Hospital in Pittsburgh at age 76, according to the Allegheny County Medical Examiner's Office.
• Copenhaver was shot in the arm and abdomen during the July 13, 2024, rally, suffering nerve damage, colon injuries, and loss of feeling in his leg.
• Copenhaver and his wife filed a lawsuit in June against the federal government, alleging Secret Service negligence in providing security at the rally.
• President Trump called Copenhaver a 'true American Patriot' who showed 'tremendous bravery' in his post-shooting recovery.
• Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro condemned the political violence, urging a reduction in hateful rhetoric.

Background

Copenhaver was one of three attendees shot during the July 13, 2024, campaign rally in Butler, Pennsylvania. The shooting, carried out by 20-year-old Thomas Crooks, resulted in the death of Corey Comperatore and injuries to Copenhaver and David Dutch. Copenhaver's injuries required multiple surgeries, including a colon transection, and he relied on a cane for mobility. The incident prompted a Secret Service investigation and a federal lawsuit by Copenhaver and his wife, alleging inadequate security measures.

How outlets are covering it

WTAE and The Guardian reported that Copenhaver died at West Penn Hospital, with his lawyer Joseph Feldman stating he was surrounded by loved ones but not specifying if his death was directly related to his rally injuries. CNN and CBS News noted that Copenhaver's attorney Douglas Latto declined to confirm if his injuries contributed to his death due to pending litigation. CBS News cited Pennsylvania Attorney General Dave Sunday, who stated Copenhaver died from complications stemming from his wounds. The Guardian emphasized the severity of Copenhaver's injuries, including nerve damage and loss of feeling in his leg, while CNN highlighted his lawsuit against the federal government for Secret Service negligence. Political responses varied, with Trump praising Copenhaver's bravery and Governor Shapiro condemning the violence and calling for reduced political rhetoric.

Why it matters

Copenhaver's death underscores the long-term physical and legal consequences for survivors of political violence. His lawsuit against the federal government raises questions about the adequacy of Secret Service security protocols for high-profile political events. The incident also highlights the ongoing debate over political rhetoric and its potential to incite violence, as emphasized by Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro. Copenhaver's case serves as a reminder of the human cost of political violence and the challenges faced by those affected by such attacks.

What to watch

The federal lawsuit filed by Copenhaver and his wife against the Secret Service and Department of Homeland Security is ongoing, with both sides agreeing to extend the deadline for the government's response. The case may set a precedent for accountability in the security of political events. Additionally, the death of Copenhaver may prompt further scrutiny of the Secret Service's security measures and the long-term support provided to victims of political violence.