Nominee James Sullivan Fails to Define 22nd Amendment, Cites Ethics to Dodge Third-Term Question

2 min read
Source: The Daily Beast
Nominee James Sullivan Fails to Define 22nd Amendment, Cites Ethics to Dodge Third-Term Question
Photo: The Daily Beast
TL;DR

Texas Supreme Court Justice James Sullivan struggled to define the 22nd Amendment during his confirmation hearing and refused to state whether President Trump could serve a third term, citing judicial ethics rules. Sen. Chris Coons criticized the response as evasive, noting the constitutional limit on terms is not a matter of political debate.

Key points

  • Sullivan, nominated to the U.S. Court for the Western District of Texas, could not recall the text of the 22nd Amendment without prompting from Sen. Coons.
  • When asked if Trump is eligible to run in 2028, Sullivan declined to answer, invoking Canon 5 regarding judicial political activity.
  • Coons argued the question is not subject to genuine legal debate, unlike unsettled jurisprudential issues, and called the response disappointing.
  • Another nominee, William Lambert, confirmed that the 22nd Amendment clearly prohibits a third term for any president, including Trump.
  • Sullivan lost his Texas Supreme Court reelection bid earlier this month before being nominated for a lifetime federal appointment.

Background

Recent federal court proceedings have seen judges question the administration's legal arguments regarding election integrity and presidential records. In October, 9th Circuit and D.C. Circuit panels expressed skepticism about DOJ actions to halt ballot counting and claims that presidential records are private property. These events highlight ongoing tensions between the executive branch and the judiciary over constitutional boundaries.

Why it matters

The incident raises concerns about the preparedness and impartiality of judicial nominees. Coons’s criticism suggests that nominees may be using ethical guidelines to avoid addressing clear constitutional limits, potentially undermining public confidence in the independence of the federal bench.

What to watch

The Senate Judiciary Committee will continue its confirmation hearings, likely scrutinizing nominees’ adherence to constitutional principles. Coons indicated he would continue questioning nominees on clear legal matters to test their willingness to provide definitive answers.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on The Daily Beast