Court documents reveal driver failed to brake before fatal Milligan cycling team crash

Key points

• John Benfield, 69, of Newland, N.C., was charged with two counts of vehicular homicide by recklessness and five counts of aggravated assault by vehicle.
• The crash occurred on Aug. 19, 2026, on U.S. Highway 19E near Simerly Creek Road in Hampton, Tenn., killing Milligan University sophomores Haylan Engdahl and Brayden Rodgers.
• An affidavit states investigators found no physical evidence that Benfield applied brakes or took evasive action before hitting the cyclists.
• Benfield was driving a 2003 Subaru Baja Sport and was in the outside lane behind another vehicle when the crash occurred.
• Nine other cyclists were injured in the crash, with several transported to Johnson City Medical Center.
• Benfield's bond was set at $150,000, and prosecutors indicated additional charges may be filed.

Background

This incident follows earlier reports from August 19-20, 2026, which confirmed the deaths of two Milligan University cycling team members and injuries to multiple others. Initial reports noted seven injured cyclists, with six remaining hospitalized in critical condition. The crash occurred during a training session on a rural highway in Carter County, Tennessee.

How outlets are covering it

WPDE and WataugaOnline.com both report on the newly obtained affidavit detailing the crash mechanics. Both outlets emphasize the lack of braking evidence. WataugaOnline.com provides additional detail that the driver was in the outside lane behind another vehicle, while WPDE focuses on the affidavit's findings regarding the driver's failure to react. Both note that marijuana odor was detected but no impairment was alleged in the affidavit.

Why it matters

The case highlights the legal consequences of reckless driving in mass-casualty incidents and the ongoing investigation into a crash that killed two student athletes. The release of the affidavit provides critical details for the prosecution and public understanding of the crash circumstances.

What to watch

Prosecutors may file additional charges as the investigation continues. Benfield will face trial on the current charges of vehicular homicide and aggravated assault. The families of the victims and the Milligan University community await the legal outcome.