Week 2 Fantasy Football: Mayfield, Jones, and London Lead Start-Sit Debate

Key points

• Baker Mayfield is a top start for Week 2 despite three fumbles in Week 1, as his advanced metrics remain strong and he faces a weak Cleveland defense.
• Aaron Jones is a must-start after Jordan Mason was placed on injured reserve, with experts projecting a significant increase in his workload and route participation.
• Drake London is recommended to be benched this week due to Cooper Rush’s poor performance, but his value is expected to rebound once Michael Penix Jr. returns.
• Dontayvion Wicks is a contentious flex option, with FantasyPros advising a start based on high snap share, while NBC Sports and CBS Sports suggest sitting him due to low target volume.
• Waiver wire sleepers include Kendre Miller and Alvin Kamara for the Saints, and Mack Hollins for the Patriots, offering value for managers in deeper leagues.

Background

Week 1 of the 2026 NFL season produced significant volatility, with players like Tyler Shough and Kyle Monangai posting standout performances, while others like Tony Pollard and Terry McLaurin underperformed. Injuries to key players such as A.J. Brown, Michael Pittman, and Jordan Mason have reshaped fantasy strategies, creating opportunities for backup players and waiver wire sleepers. The 2026 fantasy draft saw experts targeting players like Malik Willis and Kyle Pitts, but early-season performances have forced managers to reassess their rosters.

How outlets are covering it

FantasyPros and CBS Sports are bullish on Baker Mayfield, citing his strong advanced metrics and favorable matchup against Cleveland, despite his three fumbles in Week 1. NBC Sports also supports Mayfield but notes his turnover issues. In contrast, some analysts caution against overreacting to his Week 1 performance. On the other hand, Dontayvion Wicks is a point of contention: FantasyPros recommends starting him based on his high snap share and air yards, while NBC Sports and CBS Sports suggest sitting him due to low target volume. For Aaron Jones, all sources agree on his must-start status after Jordan Mason’s injury, but FantasyPros emphasizes his increased route participation, while NBC Sports highlights his carry volume. Drake London is universally recommended to be benched this week due to Cooper Rush’s poor performance, but his long-term value is expected to rebound with Michael Penix Jr.’s return.

Why it matters

Week 2 fantasy football decisions are critical for setting the tone of the season, as early performances can influence long-term roster strategies. Injuries to key players like Jordan Mason and A.J. Brown have created opportunities for backup players and waiver wire sleepers, while volatile performances by players like Baker Mayfield and Dontayvion Wicks highlight the importance of advanced metrics and matchup analysis. Managers who make informed decisions based on these factors can gain a competitive edge in their leagues.

What to watch

Managers should monitor injury updates for players like Michael Penix Jr. and A.J. Brown, as their returns could significantly impact fantasy values. Waiver wire sleepers like Kendre Miller and Mack Hollins should be added in deeper leagues, while managers should prepare for potential changes in lineup decisions as the season progresses. The next few weeks will be crucial for assessing the long-term viability of players like Drake London and Dontayvion Wicks, as well as the impact of injuries on key players.