Dodgers Demote Ohtani to Fifth Spot in NLDS Game 3 Amid Injury Concerns

Key points

• Ohtani batted fifth in Game 3, his lowest position since 2020, replacing Max Muncy and Tommy Edman in the lineup.
• The Dodgers are 1-1 in the NLDS, with a loss in Game 3 forcing them to win two elimination games to advance.
• Ohtani has not hit a home run since August 18 and has struggled with knee and biceps injuries since mid-June.
• Manager Dave Roberts stated the lineup change was a tactical response to Chris Sale, not a permanent demotion.
• Ohtani has not pitched since July 3, 2026, due to lingering injuries, focusing solely on hitting for the remainder of the season.

Background

Ohtani's health has been a focal point since mid-June, with multiple absences and load management decisions in September. The Dodgers paused his pitching duties in August to protect his long-term health, prioritizing his availability as a hitter for the postseason. His OPS dropped significantly in the second half of the 2026 season, raising concerns about his effectiveness as a leadoff hitter.

How outlets are covering it

The Los Angeles Times emphasized Roberts' openness to moving Ohtani lower in the lineup due to his lack of discipline and injury status. USA Today highlighted the tactical nature of the change, noting it was specific to the matchup against Chris Sale and that Ohtani had previously suggested batting seventh. CBS Sports focused on the broader concern of Ohtani's compromised performance due to injuries, questioning whether the Dodgers could sustain their dynasty with this version of their superstar. All sources agreed on the impact of Ohtani's injuries on his offensive production, but differed on the interpretation of the lineup change as a temporary tactical adjustment versus a sign of deeper issues.

Why it matters

The decision to move Ohtani reflects the Dodgers' strategic approach to managing a star player's health and performance in a high-stakes playoff series. It underscores the tension between protecting a key asset and maximizing immediate offensive output, with implications for the team's chances of advancing to the NLCS and ultimately the World Series.

What to watch

The Dodgers will face the Braves in Game 4, with Ohtani likely returning to a higher position in the lineup against right-handed pitching. The series outcome will determine whether the Dodgers advance to the NLCS or are eliminated, with Ohtani's health and performance remaining critical factors.