GTA 6 Fan Backlash Drives Zelda Remake’s Metacritic User Score Down to 8.7

A coordinated wave of negative user reviews has lowered the Metacritic score for the Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake from 9.6 to 8.7. This drop follows a similar review bombing campaign against Grand Theft Auto 6, which holds a 99 critic score but a 5.6 user score. While critics praise both titles, fan communities are engaging in cross-platform retaliation, highlighting flaws in Metacritic’s open rating system.
Key points
- The Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake’s Metacritic user rating fell from 9.6 to 8.7 within 24 hours of community ratings opening on November 6.
- Grand Theft Auto 6 holds a 99 critic Metascore, tying the all-time record, but its user score sits at 5.6 due to widespread negative reviews.
- A Reddit analysis suggests 83.8% of users who negatively rated GTA 6 did not rate the Zelda remake, while 66.5% of negative Zelda raters also rated GTA 6, indicating a targeted campaign.
- Both games received near-universal praise from professional critics, with Zelda scoring 96 and GTA 6 scoring 99, creating a stark contrast with user scores.
- The Zelda remake sold 5.2 million copies in its first four days, setting a record for the Nintendo Switch 2, despite the online controversy.
Background
The Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake launched on November 6 for the Nintendo Switch 2, featuring overhauled visuals, voice acting, and quality-of-life improvements. It quickly became a commercial success, topping physical sales charts in the UK and Japan. Meanwhile, Grand Theft Auto 6 launched to record-breaking sales, moving 32.5 million copies in its first 24 hours. Both titles are considered top contenders for Game of the Year, leading to heightened competitive tension between their respective fan bases.
How outlets are covering it
Notebookcheck reports that the drop in Zelda’s user score is a direct result of GTA 6 fans retaliating against what they perceive as a rival Game of the Year contender. The outlet notes that many negative reviews for Zelda contain insults directed at developers or players, rather than gameplay critiques. Nintendo Life offers a contrasting perspective, focusing on the emotional resonance of the remake, with a feature article discussing how the game successfully bridges generational gaps for families. Defector highlights the nostalgic appeal of the remake, praising its gameplay mechanics and visual fidelity, while noting that the controversy is a distraction from the game’s critical acclaim. Our archive confirms that the review bombing is part of a broader pattern of cross-platform retaliation, with GTA 6’s user score suffering from complaints about its narrative and performance, which fans are now projecting onto the Zelda title.
Why it matters
This incident exposes significant vulnerabilities in Metacritic’s user rating system, which allows anyone with an email address to submit reviews without verifying game ownership. The coordinated nature of the review bombing demonstrates how easily user scores can be manipulated, potentially misleading consumers and distorting the perceived quality of major releases. It also highlights the intense rivalry between fan communities for high-profile titles, which can overshadow the actual quality of the games and impact their commercial performance, despite both titles achieving record-breaking sales and critical acclaim.
What to watch
The Metacritic user scores for both titles may continue to fluctuate as the review bombing campaigns evolve. Nintendo and Rockstar Games may issue statements addressing the controversy, though both companies have generally avoided engaging with online fan disputes. The long-term impact on sales is likely minimal, given the strong initial performance of both games, but the incident may influence future platform policies regarding user review verification. Additionally, the ongoing rivalry between the two titles may continue to dominate gaming news cycles as they compete for Game of the Year awards.
- Zelda: Ocarina of Time Metacritic user rating sinks in response to GTA 6 review bombing Notebookcheck
- Feature: A Lost Box Restored My Faith In Zelda's Staying Power Nintendo Life
- There’s Comfort In Conquering The Past Defector
- Lady Brittany of House Broski heard Link’s call! Nintendo
- Ocarina of Time Hits $54.99 on Switch 2, $5 Off shattered.io
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on Notebookcheck