DOJ Abandons Alaska Senate Lawsuit After Peltola Wins Majority

The Trump administration has moved to dismiss its lawsuit seeking to block the certification of Democrat Mary Peltola's victory in the Alaska U.S. Senate race. The Justice Department filed a motion on November 19, 2026, asking the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to declare the case moot, effectively ending a legal challenge that threatened to prevent Peltola from taking office. This decision follows Peltola's outright majority win, which secured the 56th Senate seat for Democrats and marked the ninth Republican seat lost in the midterm elections. The lawsuit centered on the presence of a second candidate named Daniel J. Sullivan, whom the administration alleged was recruited by Peltola's campaign to confuse voters. However, the Alaska Supreme Court had previously ruled the second candidate's ballot placement legal, and a federal judge had already dismissed the initial case. Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward acknowledged in the filing that there was no longer a means to determine voter intent due to ballot secrecy. Peltola responded by stating she is eager to move forward and work for all Alaskans. This dismissal is the second high-profile election lawsuit dropped by the DOJ since the November 3 election, following a similar withdrawal in California regarding ballot counting.
Key points
- The Justice Department moved to have the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals declare its Alaska Senate lawsuit moot on November 19, 2026, two days after the race was decided.
- Mary Peltola won an outright majority in the Alaska Senate race, becoming the 56th Democrat in the Senate and the ninth Republican seat flipped in the midterm elections.
- The lawsuit challenged the certification of results due to the presence of a second candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan, whom the administration alleged was used to confuse voters.
- Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward acknowledged that ballot secrecy prevented any investigation into voter intent, rendering the case moot.
- Alaska state officials, controlled by Republicans, had previously objected to the lawsuit, calling it legally meritless and filing papers to help dismiss it.
- The Alaska Supreme Court had already ruled that the second Sullivan's candidacy was legal and that he could appear on the ballot.
Background
The dispute began in late October 2026 when the Trump administration filed a lawsuit seeking to block Alaska from certifying the Senate race results, alleging that a second candidate named Daniel J. Sullivan was recruited by Peltola's campaign to confuse voters. The Alaska Supreme Court had previously ruled the second candidate's ballot placement legal. A federal judge dismissed the initial case in early November 2026, and Alaska state officials had filed papers to help dismiss the case, calling it legally meritless. The lawsuit was part of a broader pattern of federal legal challenges to the 2026 midterms, which courts largely rejected as legally weak. The DOJ had also dropped a similar lawsuit in California seeking to prevent the counting of roughly 20,000 ballots, alleging they belonged to suspected noncitizens, but election officials questioned the validity of the data.
How outlets are covering it
CBS News and The New York Times both report that the Trump administration moved to dismiss its lawsuit over the Alaska Senate race, with CBS emphasizing the administration's 'much-criticized gambit' and The New York Times highlighting the abandonment of a legal maneuver that threatened to prevent Peltola from taking office. The Guardian focuses on the broader implications of Peltola's victory, noting that it secures a 56-seat Democratic majority in the Senate, the largest for the party in nearly two decades, and provides fuel for Democrats to take on Trump. CBS and The New York Times note that the Alaska Supreme Court had already ruled the second Sullivan's candidacy legal, while The Guardian emphasizes the political earthquake of the midterm elections, with Democrats winning more than twice the number of seats needed to gain control of the Senate. All sources agree that the lawsuit was dismissed after Peltola won an outright majority, but they differ in emphasis, with CBS and The New York Times focusing on the legal battle and The Guardian on the political implications.
Why it matters
The dismissal of the Alaska Senate lawsuit marks a significant defeat for the Trump administration's efforts to interfere in state election certification, reinforcing the legal boundaries of federal intervention in state-run elections. Peltola's victory secures a 56-seat Democratic majority in the Senate, the largest for the party in nearly two decades, providing Democrats with the strength to pursue an aggressive agenda of investigating and lawmaking. The case also highlights the limits of using legal challenges to block election results, as the Alaska Supreme Court and federal judges had already ruled the second Sullivan's candidacy legal and dismissed the initial lawsuit. The dismissal is part of a broader pattern of federal legal challenges to the 2026 midterms, which courts largely rejected as legally weak, and signals a shift in the political landscape as Democrats gain control of both chambers of Congress.
What to watch
Mary Peltola is expected to take office as the 56th Democrat in the Senate, with the 120th Congress set to be sworn in on January 3, 2026. Senate Democrats must sort out their internal affairs, including a challenge to Chuck Schumer for the role of majority leader, with a behind-closed-doors vote scheduled for December 1, 2026. The new Democratic majority will face challenges in passing legislation due to the filibuster and the need for Republican votes, but they have vowed to pursue an aggressive agenda on issues such as healthcare costs and tariff repeal. The Trump administration is expected to continue its legal challenges to election results, but the dismissal of the Alaska lawsuit signals a potential shift in the political landscape as Democrats gain control of Congress.
- Trump administration moves to dismiss lawsuit over Alaska Senate race CBS News
- Justice Department Gives Up on Alaska Senate Lawsuit The New York Times
- Live updates: Justice Department moves to have lawsuit dismissed in challenge to Alaska’s US Senate race AP News
- ‘A new day in the Senate’: 56-44 majority gives Democrats fuel to take on Trump The Guardian
- Justice Dept. drops appeal in bid to delay certification of Alaska Senate win The Washington Post
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on CBS News