Sir Trevor Phillips urges CBS News staff to ignore critics and maintain objectivity
Sir Trevor Phillips told CBS News colleagues to ignore external critics and focus on their jobs during a tense London bureau meeting. He defended foreign editor Shayndi Raice, who warned that disobeying editors constitutes insubordination. Phillips, a recent hire, emphasized the need for objectivity and mutual support amidst accusations that the network is shifting toward conservative-friendly coverage under new ownership.
Key points
- Sir Trevor Phillips advised CBS News staff to tell critics to 'fuck off' and let them do their jobs, according to a Guardian review of an audio recording.
- The comment was made during a contentious meeting where foreign editor Shayndi Raice criticized unnamed staffers for labeling editorial oversight as 'interference'.
- Raice warned that disobeying editors is insubordination and provides 'legal grounds for firing'.
- Phillips defended Raice, stating her message was 'common sense' and surprising for an organization of CBS's 'vintage and capability'.
- Phillips noted that he faced criticism when he joined CBS in June, with some predicting his career would end due to the network's perceived shift.
- He argued that journalists must maintain objectivity and support each other to avoid being manipulated by external pressures.
Background
This incident occurs amid significant changes at CBS News following the acquisition of Paramount Global by David Ellison’s Skydance Media in summer 2025. Ellison installed Bari Weiss as editor-in-chief, a move that shook staff and led to accusations of tilting editorial scales toward a conservative-friendly direction. Previous coverage noted Weiss’s aim to appeal to the political center and a broader strategy amid a potential Warner Bros. Discovery merger, while also highlighting staff reactions to firings at 60 Minutes and other shakeups.
Why it matters
The incident highlights internal tensions at CBS News as it navigates a transition in ownership and leadership. It underscores concerns about editorial independence and the pressure on journalists to maintain objectivity amidst external criticism and internal directives. The reaction from a senior figure like Phillips indicates a desire to insulate the newsroom from external influence, which is critical for maintaining credibility in a polarized media landscape.
What to watch
CBS News and Phillips have declined to comment on the meeting. The network will likely continue to face scrutiny over its editorial direction under Bari Weiss and David Ellison. Staff may continue to grapple with the balance between following editorial directives and maintaining perceived independence, as highlighted by the internal debate over what constitutes 'interference' versus legitimate oversight.
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on The Guardian