Critics praise Andrew Scott’s raw performance in 'Elsinore' but criticize director Simon Stone’s heavy-handed direction

4 min read
Source: NPR
Critics praise Andrew Scott’s raw performance in 'Elsinore' but criticize director Simon Stone’s heavy-handed direction
Photo: NPR
TL;DR

The biographical drama 'Elsinore' chronicles the final months of Scottish actor Ian Charleson, who performed Hamlet at London’s National Theatre in 1989 while dying of AIDS. Andrew Scott delivers a widely praised performance as Charleson, but critics argue director Simon Stone undermines the film’s emotional impact with excessive musical scoring and melodramatic choices. The film, which opened in theaters on November 20, 2026, also features Olivia Colman as HIV pioneer Margaret Johnson and David Dawson as filmmaker Derek Jarman.

Key points

  • Andrew Scott portrays Ian Charleson, a gay actor who took over the role of Hamlet at the National Theatre in 1989 after Daniel Day-Lewis dropped out, continuing to perform despite a terminal AIDS diagnosis.
  • Ian Charleson completed 24 performances of Hamlet before his death in January 1990 at age 40; the film focuses on his final months in 1989, including his time in the Royal Free Hospital’s AIDS ward.
  • Olivia Colman plays Margaret Johnson, the UK’s first HIV physician, who opposes Charleson’s decision to continue performing, arguing that life should be preserved rather than measured by quality.
  • David Dawson plays filmmaker Derek Jarman, who had a falling out with Charleson over credit for his first acting role in the 1978 film Jubilee and his refusal to come out publicly.
  • The film was directed by Simon Stone and written by Stephen Beresford, with a runtime of 1 hour 51 minutes, and is rated R.
  • Andrew Scott wore blue contact lenses to mimic Charleson’s eye color and had to 'unlearn' his previous 150 performances of Hamlet to approach the role authentically.

Background

The film 'Elsinore' is part of a recent wave of Shakespeare-related productions, including a 2025 adaptation starring Riz Ahmed and a documentary about a theater production starring Oscar Isaac. It also joins a broader cultural conversation about AIDS representation in media, following earlier coverage of the AIDS crisis’s impact on financial markets and public health. The film’s release coincides with renewed interest in historical biographical dramas that explore the intersection of art, illness, and identity, particularly in the context of LGBTQ+ history and the 1980s AIDS epidemic.

How outlets are covering it

NPR’s review highlights Andrew Scott’s 'searing and unforgettable' performance but criticizes director Simon Stone for 'second-guessing himself' with 'dramaturgical training wheels,' including an overly insistent score and conventional AIDS-drama tropes. The New York Times’ Alissa Wilkinson calls the film a 'Critic’s Pick' and praises Scott as 'magnificent,' but notes the film’s reliance on Hamlet’s existential themes to explore mortality. The New Yorker’s Justin Chang argues that Scott’s performance 'outshines the cliché-ridden filmmaking,' criticizing Stone’s 'more-is-more' approach and the film’s 'monotonous' montages, while also noting that the depiction of Derek Jarman is 'corrected and diminished' by recent archival footage in the documentary 'Queer Edward II.' People.com provides a factual overview of the cast and their real-life counterparts, emphasizing the film’s historical accuracy and the courage of Charleson’s decision to perform while dying. All sources agree on the strength of Scott’s performance but diverge on the film’s overall execution, with NPR and The New Yorker being the most critical of Stone’s direction, while The New York Times offers a more balanced, positive assessment.

Why it matters

The film 'Elsinore' serves as a cultural touchstone for discussions about the AIDS crisis, LGBTQ+ history, and the intersection of art and mortality. It highlights the courage of individuals who chose to create and perform despite terminal illness, challenging conventional narratives about the 1980s AIDS epidemic. The film’s critical reception underscores the tension between authentic, restrained storytelling and melodramatic, emotionally manipulative filmmaking, raising questions about how historical biographical dramas should balance factual accuracy with dramatic license. Additionally, the film’s focus on Ian Charleson’s decision to remain closeted while performing Hamlet invites reflection on the complexities of visibility, identity, and legacy in the context of the AIDS crisis and the broader LGBTQ+ movement.

What to watch

The film 'Elsinore' is expected to be a contender for the 2027 Academy Awards, with Andrew Scott widely tipped for a Best Actor nomination. The film’s release in theaters on November 20, 2026, is likely to spark further critical and public discussion about its portrayal of historical figures and events. The documentary 'Queer Edward II,' which features newly discovered archival footage of Derek Jarman, may also gain attention as a counterpoint to the film’s depiction of Jarman. The film’s success or failure at the box office and awards season will likely influence future biographical dramas about historical figures and the AIDS crisis.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on NPR