Andrew Scott Defends 'Elsinore' Against Queer Joy Critics at London Film Festival
Andrew Scott used the BFI London Film Festival to defend his new film 'Elsinore' against critics who prefer lighter queer narratives. Scott argued that avoiding the AIDS crisis stems from misplaced shame, emphasizing that the stigma belongs to governments, not gay people. The film, which opened the festival, is already generating Oscar buzz.
Key points
- Andrew Scott stated that avoiding painful queer history like the AIDS crisis is a form of shame that belongs to governments, not gay people.
- The film 'Elsinore' opened the 70th BFI London Film Festival, with Scott bringing real-life figures like Dr. Margaret Johnson onto the stage.
- Scott described the premiere as a 'very special evening' and noted that the film is likely to be a major awards contender.
- Variety and The Hollywood Reporter reported that Scott welcomed joyful queer media like 'Heated Rivalry' but insisted darker historical stories must still be told.
- RTE.ie highlighted Scott's desire to celebrate Ian Charleson's zest for life, not just his tragic death from AIDS.
Background
Our earlier coverage noted that 'Elsinore' received strong reviews at Telluride and was expected to enter the awards race. The film parallels the 1989 National Theatre production of 'Hamlet' with the real-life AIDS crisis, a theme that resonates with ongoing global discussions about HIV stigma and medical history.
How outlets are covering it
The Hollywood Reporter and Variety both captured Scott's direct pushback against the idea that 'sad gays' are unwelcome, framing his comments as a defense of historical accuracy. RTE.ie offered a softer perspective, focusing on Scott's intent to highlight Charleson's charm and vitality rather than just his illness. While all sources agree on the film's emotional impact, THR and Variety emphasized the political weight of Scott's comments on shame, whereas RTE.ie focused on the biographical tribute.
Why it matters
The film's premiere signals a potential Oscar campaign for Andrew Scott, while his public stance challenges the current trend in LGBTQ+ media toward exclusively joyful narratives, forcing a conversation about the necessity of remembering traumatic historical periods.
What to watch
The film is expected to continue its awards season push, with Scott likely to be a frontrunner for acting nominations. The London Film Festival runs until October 18, providing further opportunities for press and audience engagement.
- Andrew Scott Welcomes ‘Heated Rivalry,’ But Feels “Troubled” by Those Who “Don’t Want to See” Painful Queer History The Hollywood Reporter
- Elsinore review — Andrew Scott’s tearjerker will win him an Oscar The Times
- Andrew Scott is astonishing as a dying actor in Elsinore The Telegraph
- 'Elsinore' Star Andrew Scott on Why Films Should Tackle the AIDS Crisis Variety
- Andrew Scott on 'very special' role in new film Elsinore RTE.ie
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on The Hollywood Reporter