Andrew Scott’s ‘Elsinore’ Performance Shifts Oscar Race at Telluride
Andrew Scott has emerged as a top contender for the Best Actor Oscar following his world premiere of 'Elsinore' at the Telluride Film Festival. His portrayal of Ian Charleson, a real-life actor who continued performing while battling AIDS, received a standing ovation and is described as a career-defining performance. This development challenges the earlier frontrunner status of John Malkovich, whose film 'Wild Horse Nine' premiered the day prior. While Malkovich benefits from his age and a film likely to secure multiple nominations, Scott’s performance is considered so powerful it may overshadow other aspects of his film. Additionally, Scott is noted as a potential historic first: the first openly gay actor to win the Oscar, as no out gay actor or actress has ever won the award, despite previous winners portraying LGBT characters.
Key points
- Andrew Scott’s performance in 'Elsinore' was met with a standing ovation at its Telluride world premiere, shifting him into the top tier of the Best Actor Oscar race.
- The film depicts the real-life story of Ian Charleson, who continued acting in 'Hamlet' at London’s National Theatre after being diagnosed with terminal AIDS.
- John Malkovich was considered the frontrunner after his film 'Wild Horse Nine' premiered at Telluride, but Scott’s performance is now seen as a stronger contender due to its raw impact.
- Malkovich holds an advantage due to his age (73 vs. 49) and the likelihood that 'Wild Horse Nine' will receive multiple nominations, including Best Picture, whereas 'Elsinore' is less certain in other categories.
- Andrew Scott could become the first openly gay actor to win an Oscar, as no out gay actor or actress has ever won the award, despite previous winners portraying LGBT characters.
- Other potential nominations for 'Elsinore' include Olivia Colman for Best Supporting Actress, Stephen Beresford for Best Original Screenplay, and Valerio Bonelli for Best Film Editing.
Background
The Telluride Film Festival has historically served as a bellwether for the Oscar race, with its 2026 lineup featuring strong contenders like 'Elsinore' and 'Wild Horse Nine.' Andrew Scott’s previous performance in 'All of Us Strangers' also premiered at Telluride three years ago, establishing his trajectory as a leading actor. The festival’s 2026 program included other notable films such as Mike Leigh’s 'Tender Loving Care' and Jesse Eisenberg’s 'The Debut,' highlighting its role in shaping the awards landscape.
Why it matters
Andrew Scott’s potential Oscar win would be a historic milestone for representation in Hollywood, as no openly gay actor or actress has ever won the award. His performance in 'Elsinore' not only challenges the current frontrunner but also highlights the power of real-life stories in cinema. The film’s potential for multiple nominations, including Best Picture, could further elevate its status in the awards season, making it a key contender in the 2026 Oscar race.
What to watch
The next steps for 'Elsinore' and Andrew Scott include securing additional nominations in categories such as Best Supporting Actress, Best Original Screenplay, and Best Film Editing. The film’s performance in other awards categories will be crucial in determining its overall standing in the Oscar race. Additionally, the reaction to Scott’s performance at other festivals and in the broader industry will influence his chances of winning the Best Actor Oscar.
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on The Hollywood Reporter