Andrew Scott’s ‘Elsinore’ Depicts Ian Charleson’s Final Hamlet Amidst AIDS Crisis

The biographical drama 'Elsinore' chronicles the final months of Scottish actor Ian Charleson, who performed Shakespeare's 'Hamlet' at London’s National Theatre in 1989 while dying of AIDS. Andrew Scott delivers a widely praised performance as Charleson, capturing the actor's wit and determination to stage a career-defining role despite severe health decline. The film explores the intersection of art and mortality, avoiding sentimentalized portrayals of the AIDS crisis by focusing on Charleson's humor and professional pride. Scott, who is openly gay, notes that such casting was unlikely a decade ago, highlighting shifting industry norms. The film has generated significant Oscar buzz, with Scott potentially becoming the first openly gay actor to win Best Actor if he takes the award.
Key points
- Andrew Scott portrays Ian Charleson in 'Elsinore,' depicting the actor's 1989 performance of 'Hamlet' at the National Theatre while battling AIDS.
- Charleson replaced Daniel Day-Lewis, who dropped out of the production, and completed 24 performances before dying in January 1990.
- Scott, who previously played Hamlet on stage in 2017, had to unlearn his own approach to embody Charleson's physical and mental decline.
- The film features Olivia Colman as HIV pioneer Margaret Johnson and David Dawson as director Derek Jarman, who criticized Charleson for remaining closeted.
- Critics praise Scott’s performance but criticize director Simon Stone for relying on excessive montages and melodramatic scoring that dilute the emotional impact.
Background
Andrew Scott is known for roles in 'Sherlock' and 'Fleabag,' but 'Elsinore' marks his first major biographical role. The film opens in select theaters on November 20, 2026, with a wider release on December 4. It arrives alongside 'I Play Rocky,' another biographical drama generating Oscar buzz, creating a rare pairing of films where the Academy Awards feature prominently in the narrative. Previous coverage noted that Scott’s performance is considered a serious contender for the Best Actor Oscar, a historic potential win as no openly gay actor has won the category before.
How outlets are covering it
The New York Times highlights the physical and emotional toll of playing Hamlet, noting Scott’s description of the role as 'multifaceted' and 'exhausting.' USA Today emphasizes the historical significance of Scott’s potential Oscar win, noting that no publicly out gay actor has won Best Actor. The New Yorker criticizes director Simon Stone’s 'more-is-more' approach, arguing that the film’s montages and musical scoring undermine the emotional depth of Charleson’s story. NPR compares 'Elsinore' to 'I Play Rocky,' noting that both films feature strong lead performances but suffer from predictable narratives and heavy-handed direction. All sources agree that Scott’s performance is the film’s strongest element, but they diverge on whether the film’s structure and direction effectively convey the tragedy of Charleson’s final months.
Why it matters
The film sheds light on the AIDS crisis of the late 1980s and the personal sacrifices made by artists to pursue their craft. It also highlights the evolving representation of LGBTQ+ actors in Hollywood, with Scott’s potential Oscar win marking a historic milestone. The film’s critical reception underscores the ongoing debate about the balance between performance and direction in biographical dramas, particularly those dealing with sensitive historical topics.
What to watch
The film will be in wide release in the United States on December 4, 2026. Oscar nominations are expected in early 2027, with Scott considered a strong contender for Best Actor. The film’s performance at the box office and its reception at the Academy Awards will determine its legacy as a biographical drama.
- Andrew Scott Plays a Dying Actor Playing Hamlet: ‘I’m Not Scared of Sadness’ The New York Times
- 'I Play Rocky' and 'Elsinore' can't land their punches, even with star performances NPR
- The Look-at-Me Spectacle of Actors Playing Actors in “Elsinore” and “I Play Rocky” The New Yorker
- Andrew Scott shares the harsh reality of playing Hamlet USA Today
- The Weekend Read: Andrew Scott, Cliff Booth, Bond & 'The Hunger Games' Deadline
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on The New York Times