Andrew Scott’s ‘Elsinore’ Honors Ian Charleson’s Final Hamlet Amidst AIDS Crisis

3 min read
Source: The New York Times
Andrew Scott’s ‘Elsinore’ Honors Ian Charleson’s Final Hamlet Amidst AIDS Crisis
Photo: The New York Times
TL;DR

The biographical drama 'Elsinore,' directed by Simon Stone, chronicles the final months of actor Ian Charleson, who performed Shakespeare's 'Hamlet' at London's National Theatre in 1989 while dying of AIDS. Andrew Scott delivers a widely praised performance as Charleson, capturing the actor's wit and determination to stage a career-defining role despite severe health decline. The film explores the intersection of art and mortality, avoiding sentimentalized portrayals of the AIDS crisis by focusing on Charleson's humor and professional pride. Scott, who is openly gay, notes that such casting was unlikely a decade ago, highlighting shifting industry norms. The film has generated significant Oscar buzz, with Scott potentially becoming the first openly gay actor to win Best Actor if he takes the award.

Key points

  • The film centers on Ian Charleson, best known for 'Chariots of Fire,' who stepped in for Daniel Day-Lewis to play Hamlet in 1989.
  • Charleson performed the role 24 times while suffering from advanced AIDS, dying eight weeks after the production concluded.
  • Andrew Scott portrays Charleson, noting that his own mother’s death in 2024 fueled his passion for the role.
  • Olivia Colman plays Dr. Margaret Johnson, a pioneering HIV researcher who opposed Charleson's decision to continue performing.
  • The film aims to avoid 'gay disaster movie' tropes, emphasizing Charleson's humor and life rather than solely his death.

Background

Recent years have seen a surge in Shakespeare-related adaptations, including 'Hamnet' and various 'Hamlet' projects. 'Elsinore' joins this trend but focuses on the historical reality of an actor’s final performance. The film also reflects broader industry shifts regarding the visibility of LGBTQ+ actors, a theme Scott discussed in interviews regarding his casting.

How outlets are covering it

The New York Times critic Alissa Wilkinson praises Andrew Scott’s performance as 'magnificent' but notes the film’s structure can feel like a 'feature-length trailer' due to heavy montage usage. NPR criticizes the film for clumsily mashing art and illness together, calling it a 'tearjerker' that lacks depth in its narrative progression. In contrast, AP News highlights the film’s success in balancing grief with celebration, calling Scott’s performance a 'shattering' landmark that could lead to an Oscar win. People.com emphasizes the cultural significance of Scott’s casting, noting that openly gay actors were rarely cast in such roles a decade ago. While all outlets agree on Scott’s talent, they diverge on the film’s structural effectiveness, with some finding it fragmented and others viewing it as a powerful tribute.

Why it matters

The film addresses the historical erasure of LGBTQ+ figures in Hollywood and the stigma surrounding AIDS in the late 1980s. It also serves as a potential Oscar milestone for Andrew Scott, who could become the first openly gay actor to win Best Actor. The story underscores the enduring relevance of Shakespeare and the human drive to create art in the face of mortality.

What to watch

The film is set to release in theaters on November 20, 2026. Andrew Scott is expected to be a leading contender for the Academy Award for Best Actor. The film’s reception may influence future biographical dramas about LGBTQ+ historical figures and AIDS-era narratives.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on The New York Times