Fielder's Holmes Documentary Achieves Perfect Score, Sparks Oscar Buzz, and Severs Ties with Subjects

Key points

• The documentary has received a perfect 100% score on Rotten Tomatoes, with critics calling it a 'masterpiece' and a 'vertiginous' spectacle.
• The film is being considered for the Best Picture category at the Academy Awards, potentially becoming the first nonfiction film to receive such a nomination.
• Elizabeth Holmes and her partner, Billy Evans, have not seen the completed film, and communication between them and the directors has broken down.
• The documentary is set for a wide theatrical release on October 16, 2026, following premieres at the Telluride and New York Film Festivals.

Background

This story follows the release of 'You Can See Everything,' a three-hour documentary that premiered to critical acclaim at the New York Film Festival in October 2026. The film, which documents the final days of Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes before her prison sentence, has generated significant buzz and debate regarding the nature of truth in documentary filmmaking.

How outlets are covering it

The Independent and The New Yorker emphasize the film's critical acclaim and its status as a 'masterpiece,' with The New Yorker highlighting its 'vertiginous revelations' and 'poetic beauty.' Variety focuses on the film's potential to make Oscars history as the first nonfiction Best Picture nominee, noting the challenges it faces from the Academy's documentary branch. The Mercury News highlights the breakdown in communication between the filmmakers and the subjects, with Holmes and Evans having not seen the finished film and the relationship with Evans becoming 'uncomfortable' and 'strained.'

Why it matters

The film's perfect score and Oscar buzz demonstrate its cultural impact and the power of documentary filmmaking to challenge public narratives. The breakdown in communication between the filmmakers and the subjects highlights the complex and often contentious nature of documentary production, particularly when dealing with controversial figures.

What to watch

The film is set for a wide theatrical release on October 16, 2026. The Academy Awards nominations are expected to be announced in December 2026, with the film potentially becoming the first nonfiction film to receive a Best Picture nomination.