'Verity' Premieres to Mixed Reviews: Critics Praise Cast, Panning Script

Key points

• The New York premiere took place at AMC Lincoln Square 13 on September 29, 2026.
• The film is directed by Michael Showalter and written by Nick Antosca.
• It is based on Colleen Hoover's 2018 novel of the same name.
• Theatrical release is scheduled for October 2, 2026.
• Critics criticized the pacing, plot logic, and the director's handling of the erotic thriller genre.

Background

The film is the fourth adaptation of a Colleen Hoover novel. Previous adaptations, including 'It Ends With Us,' have generated significant box office revenue. In September, Hoover and Showalter discussed how the adaptation restored erotic elements and removed a sleepwalking subplot to improve momentum. The cast has also promoted the film in London and Los Angeles.

How outlets are covering it

Deadline provided a neutral photo gallery of the premiere, highlighting the attendance of the main cast and producers. In contrast, Variety and The Guardian offered negative critical reviews. Variety's Guy Lodge called the film a 'flat-footed dud' and 'listless,' criticizing the director's lack of feel for the genre and the actors' apparent indifference. The Guardian's reviewer found the film 'silly and entertaining' initially but argued the third act 'disintegrates' and the narrative structure is flawed. Both outlets noted the film's reliance on a 'Rebecca'-style gothic atmosphere but found it lacking in execution.

Why it matters

The film represents a major commercial push by Amazon MGM Studios to capitalize on the popularity of Colleen Hoover's books. The critical reception highlights the challenges of adapting best-selling novels into films, particularly in the erotic thriller genre, and may impact the studio's strategy for future adaptations.

What to watch

The film is scheduled for wide theatrical release on October 2, 2026. Box office performance will be a key indicator of its success, given the mixed critical reception.