Federal Judge Ends Lizzo’s Tour Staffer Harassment Suit, Citing 'Ordinary Tribulations'

5 min read
Source: nytimes.com
Federal Judge Ends Lizzo’s Tour Staffer Harassment Suit, Citing 'Ordinary Tribulations'
Photo: nytimes.com
TL;DR

A federal judge has fully dismissed a harassment and discrimination lawsuit against singer Lizzo and her touring company, Big Grrrl Touring. The ruling concludes a case brought by former wardrobe designer Asha Daniels, who alleged sexual harassment, racial bias, and disability discrimination during Lizzo’s 2023 tour. Judge Fernando Aenlle-Rocha ruled that the alleged incidents were isolated and did not meet the legal threshold for a hostile work environment under Title VII. While Lizzo’s legal team called the outcome a 'total victory,' Daniels’ attorneys expressed disappointment and are considering next steps. This dismissal resolves one of several legal challenges facing the artist, though a separate lawsuit from three former backup dancers remains pending.

Key points

  • Judge Fernando Aenlle-Rocha of the U.S. District Court in Los Angeles granted summary judgment to Lizzo and Big Grrrl Touring on September 1, 2026.
  • The lawsuit was filed by Asha Daniels, a former wardrobe designer, who alleged sexual harassment, racial, gender, and disability discrimination during the European leg of Lizzo’s 2023 tour.
  • The judge ruled that alleged incidents, including 'lewd gestures' and sexual jokes by a male coworker, were isolated and not directed at Daniels, falling under the 'ordinary tribulations of the workplace.'
  • The court found no evidence to support claims that tour manager Amanda Nomura used racial slurs or that Lizzo used such language to describe other Black artists.
  • Lizzo’s attorney Melissa Y. Glass described the dismissal as a 'total victory' in a 'ludicrous' legal action, while Daniels’ counsel Ron Zambrano stated the ruling improperly weighed evidence and minimized the cumulative impact of the alleged conduct.
  • Lizzo had been dismissed as an individual defendant in December 2024, but the case against her touring company continued until this final dismissal.

Background

This ruling concludes a specific legal dispute that began in 2023, shortly after Lizzo faced a high-profile lawsuit from three former backup dancers alleging sexual harassment and weight-shaming. Asha Daniels filed her own suit around the same time, making similar accusations of a hostile work environment. In 2024, Judge Aenlle-Rocha dismissed Lizzo as an individual defendant, but the case against her company, Big Grrrl Touring, continued through 2025 and 2026. Lizzo’s legal team had previously characterized Daniels’ claims as frivolous, arguing they were motivated by personal vendettas rather than actual discrimination. The dismissal of Daniels’ case is part of a broader pattern of legal challenges facing Lizzo, though the separate dancer lawsuit remains active.

How outlets are covering it

The New York Times reported the dismissal as a definitive end to the case, noting that the judge found the alleged conduct did not meet the legal standards for a hostile work environment. Billboard provided a more detailed breakdown of the judge’s reasoning, highlighting specific findings that there was no evidence of racial slurs or disparate treatment of women. Billboard also included direct quotes from both sides: Lizzo’s attorney called it a 'total victory' in a 'ludicrous' case, while Daniels’ attorney criticized the ruling for 'improperly weighing evidence' and minimizing the cumulative impact of the alleged conduct. The Yahoo source was not a news article but a technical error page, so it provided no substantive perspective on the story. The archive articles confirm that this dismissal was a significant development in a series of legal challenges, with Lizzo publicly celebrating the outcome on social media, while the separate dancer lawsuit continues to pose a legal risk.

Why it matters

The dismissal of Asha Daniels’ lawsuit marks a significant legal victory for Lizzo and her touring company, clearing one of the major legal hurdles she has faced since 2023. The judge’s ruling that the alleged incidents were 'ordinary tribulations of the workplace' sets a precedent for how courts may evaluate claims of hostile work environments in the music industry, particularly when the alleged conduct is isolated and not directed at the plaintiff. However, the separate lawsuit from three former backup dancers remains pending, and Lizzo’s attorneys are appealing a prior ruling that allowed many of those claims to proceed to trial. This ongoing legal battle could have implications for Lizzo’s ability to perform and advocate for body positivity, as her attorneys have warned. The outcome of the dancer lawsuit will be a key indicator of whether Lizzo can fully resolve the legal challenges that have accompanied her career in recent years.

What to watch

Daniels’ attorney, Ron Zambrano, stated that he and his client are 'considering appropriate next steps' after the dismissal, which could include an appeal. Lizzo’s legal team is currently appealing a prior ruling in the separate lawsuit filed by three former backup dancers, which allowed many of the claims to proceed to trial. The outcome of that appeal will determine whether the dancer lawsuit will go to trial or be dismissed. Lizzo’s attorneys have warned that the dancer lawsuit could limit her 'First Amendment right to perform her music and advocate for body positivity,' suggesting that the legal battle may continue for some time. The dismissal of Daniels’ case does not resolve all of Lizzo’s legal challenges, but it is a significant step in clearing one of the major hurdles she has faced.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on nytimes.com