Medical Examiner Report Details Pre-Fall Altercation in Franklin High Death

4 min read
Source: Los Angeles Times
Medical Examiner Report Details Pre-Fall Altercation in Franklin High Death
Photo: Los Angeles Times
TL;DR

A new Los Angeles County medical examiner report details events preceding the September 30 death of Xavier Nungaray-Martinez, a 17-year-old Franklin High School student who died after falling from a fourth-floor balcony. The report states Nungaray-Martinez punched a male student and attempted to forcibly kiss a female classmate before an altercation occurred. While the medical examiner classified the death as suicide, the family disputes this finding, alleging bullying and negligence by the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD). Attorneys for the family have filed damage claims against the district, asserting that staff failed to intervene during the incident.

Key points

  • The medical examiner’s office released a report stating Nungaray-Martinez initiated a physical altercation by punching a male student and attempting to forcibly kiss a female student, who pushed him away.
  • The report concludes the manner of death was suicide, citing blunt traumatic injuries to the head and torso, and notes a history of depression, though a redacted family member disputed the depression diagnosis.
  • Attorneys for the family filed damage claims against LAUSD, alleging the district allowed dangerous conditions and failed to protect the student from known bullying.
  • The family contests the suicide determination, arguing the student was likely disoriented or concussed from the beating and made an impulsive move to escape rather than intentionally jumping.
  • A toxicology report found Nungaray-Martinez’s body was presumed positive for marijuana, though it does not confirm he was under the influence at the time of death; no other substances were detected.

Background

Nungaray-Martinez died on September 30 after falling from a fourth-floor balcony at Benjamin Franklin High School in Highland Park. The incident prompted a three-hour campus lockdown and widespread public outcry. In October, the medical examiner initially determined the death was a suicide, a finding the family contested, claiming the student was a healthy, happy kid who was brutally attacked. The family has since called for the return of school police and stronger anti-bullying measures, while attendance at the school has declined due to trauma and hoax threats.

How outlets are covering it

The Los Angeles Times and NBC Los Angeles report that the medical examiner’s office concluded the death was a suicide, noting that Nungaray-Martinez initiated the altercation by punching a student and attempting to forcibly kiss another. However, the Times highlights discrepancies between the report’s narrative and circulating video footage, which shows the other student delivering multiple blows while Nungaray-Martinez was on the ground. ABC7 Los Angeles emphasizes the family’s legal action, with attorneys stating that LAUSD has not communicated with them and that the suicide conclusion is baseless. The family’s attorneys argue that the student was likely concussed and confused, while the medical examiner’s office cites a history of depression and the act of jumping as evidence of suicide. The Times also notes that while a toxicology report found marijuana in the system, it does not confirm use at the time of death, and the family denies any drug use.

Why it matters

The release of the medical examiner’s report adds nuance to a tragic case that has sparked broader debates about school safety, bullying, and the role of police in schools. The family’s legal claims against LAUSD may set a precedent for how districts are held accountable for student safety and anti-bullying measures. The dispute over the cause of death highlights the challenges in determining intent in cases involving trauma and potential mental health issues, and underscores the need for clear, transparent investigations in such sensitive cases.

What to watch

The family’s damage claims against LAUSD are expected to lead to a lawsuit, as one claim was rejected, clearing the way for legal action. The LAPD investigation into the death remains open. The medical examiner’s office has not responded to queries about whether Nungaray-Martinez was under the influence of marijuana at the time of death. The family continues to demand answers and accountability from the district, while the school community grapples with the trauma and declining attendance.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on Los Angeles Times