Grand Jury Indicts Two Men on Murder Charges in 2023 Road Rage Killing of Scott Spivey

A South Carolina grand jury has indicted Weldon Boyd and Kenneth 'Bradley' Williams on murder and weapon possession charges related to the September 2023 death of Scott Spivey. The indictments follow a three-year investigation and a prior denial of 'Stand Your Ground' immunity. While the defendants maintain the shooting was self-defense, the victim's family views the charges as a critical step toward accountability after years of alleged police misconduct.
Key points
- An Horry County grand jury indicted Weldon Boyd and Kenneth 'Bradley' Williams on November 18, 2026, for the murder of Scott Spivey and possession of a firearm during a violent crime.
- The charges stem from a September 9, 2023, shooting on Camp Swamp Road in Horry County, where Spivey was killed after a road rage incident.
- Boyd and Williams have consistently claimed they acted in self-defense, a position previously supported by the South Carolina Attorney General's Office under the state's 'Stand Your Ground' law.
- In February 2026, Judge Eugene Griffith denied both men's requests for immunity under the Protection of Persons and Property Act, paving the way for criminal review.
- The civil wrongful-death lawsuit filed by Spivey's sister, Jennifer Foley, has been stayed for 180 days pending the criminal proceedings.
- Former Horry County Deputy Chief Brandon Strickland is also facing an arraignment in connection with alleged misconduct during the initial police investigation.
Background
The case gained national attention after the Spivey family released records suggesting police mishandled evidence and protected the suspects. In 2024, the Attorney General's Office declined to charge the men, citing insufficient evidence. However, new investigations into police misconduct led Attorney General Alan Wilson to request a review by an outside prosecutor, Barry Barnette, in late 2025. This review resulted in the grand jury impanelment in February 2026, which ultimately led to the current indictments.
How outlets are covering it
The Spivey family, represented by attorney Mark Tinsley, views the indictments as a necessary correction of a flawed official narrative, emphasizing that the family had to fight the system to uncover the truth. Conversely, the defense attorneys for Boyd and Williams argue that the case is a clear instance of self-defense, stating that the evidence has not changed and that the men were protecting their lives. While WMBF and WPDE focus on the procedural steps and the family's statement, The Post and Courier highlights the parallel arraignment of former police official Brandon Strickland, suggesting a broader scrutiny of the initial law enforcement response. Yahoo News frames the story as a reversal of the 'Stand Your Ground' protection that had previously shielded the defendants from criminal liability.
Why it matters
This case highlights the complexities of self-defense laws in South Carolina and the potential for criminal charges to emerge years after an incident if new evidence or misconduct is uncovered. It also underscores the role of civil litigation in uncovering facts that may influence criminal proceedings, as well as the ongoing scrutiny of police conduct in high-profile cases.
What to watch
Boyd and Williams are scheduled to appear in Kershaw County on November 19 for a hearing, likely an arraignment. The civil wrongful-death lawsuit remains stayed for 180 days, though it could be lifted if circumstances change. The outcome of the criminal trial will determine whether the 'Stand Your Ground' defense holds up in a criminal context, potentially setting a precedent for similar cases in South Carolina.
- Boyd, Williams indicted on murder charges in Scott Spivey’s death WMBF
- Men who killed Scott Spivey indicted on murder charges in Horry County Post and Courier
- 2 accused in death of Scott Spivey indicted by grand jury WPDE
- Grand jury indicts Weldon Boyd, Kenneth Williams on murder charges in Scott Spivey killing WBTW
- Stand Your Ground shielded 2 men in a road rage killing. Now they face murder charges Yahoo
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on WMBF