Costa Rican police arrest surf legend Kurt Van Dyke’s girlfriend in February murder case

Costa Rican authorities arrested the former girlfriend of 66-year-old surfing legend Kurt Van Dyke and a second male suspect in connection with his February 2026 murder. Investigators allege the pair staged a robbery to steal bank card codes for a hotel Van Dyke owned, contradicting the initial report of a home invasion.
Key points
- Kurt Van Dyke, a prominent Santa Cruz, California surfer, was found dead in his Costa Rican home on February 14 with stab wounds and signs of asphyxiation.
- Police arrested 31-year-old Arroyo, Van Dyke’s former girlfriend, and 34-year-old Gutiérrez in raids across three homes in Roxana, Pococí, last week.
- Investigators allege the suspects planned a robbery to obtain PIN codes for bank cards linked to a hotel Van Dyke owned, rather than the initial reported home invasion.
- Arroyo survived the attack and initially claimed she was restrained by armed men, but police now believe her account was a cover story supported by evidence of a staged car theft.
- Van Dyke’s brother, Peter Van Dyke, expressed satisfaction with the arrests after a nine-month investigation, noting the family’s focus is now on justice.
Background
Van Dyke was a well-known figure in the surfing community, having lived in Costa Rica since the 1980s. He was part of a legendary surfing family; his father, Gene Van Dyke, pioneered surfing in Northern California in the 1950s, and his mother, Betty, was an early competitive champion. Van Dyke owned a hostel in Puerto Viejo de Talamanca. This case follows other high-profile crimes against expatriates in Costa Rica, including the recent arrest of a suspect in the homicide of American businessman Marc Walter Fleming in Guanacaste.
How outlets are covering it
Fox News and the Los Angeles Times emphasize the shift in the investigation from a home invasion to a premeditated robbery, highlighting the staged nature of the crime. CBS News focuses on the emotional response of Van Dyke’s family, particularly his brother Peter, who described the girlfriend’s involvement as 'shocking' but expressed faith in Costa Rican law enforcement. All outlets agree on the core facts of the arrests and the suspects’ alleged motives, but differ in emphasis: Fox and LA Times detail the forensic evidence (staged car theft, zip-tie claims), while CBS centers on the family’s perspective and the timeline of the investigation.
Why it matters
The case highlights the vulnerability of expatriates in Costa Rica and the complexity of investigating crimes that may involve local accomplices. It also underscores the importance of thorough investigations, as initial reports of a home invasion were later contradicted by evidence of a planned robbery. The arrests may lead to further charges and a trial, potentially involving additional suspects still at large.
What to watch
Arroyo and Gutiérrez have been referred to Costa Rica’s Public Ministry, which will decide whether to file formal charges. Investigators are still searching for two other men allegedly involved in the attack. Van Dyke’s eldest son is expected to attend the eventual murder trial in Costa Rica.
- Surfing legend found stabbed to death under bed – girlfriend accused of letting thugs in to wipe him out Fox News
- Brother of American killed in Costa Rica says he's focused on justice after arrest of former girlfriend CBS News
- Santa Cruz surfing legend's girlfriend arrested in his brutal killing SFGATE
- Surf legend's girlfriend said he was killed in a robbery. Authorities now suspect her in his murder Los Angeles Times
- American surfer Kurt Van Dyke's girlfriend and another man arrested for his murder Yahoo
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on Fox News