DOJ Finds Berkeley Law Violated Civil Rights Act via Race-Conscious Admissions

3 min read
Source: Fox News
DOJ Finds Berkeley Law Violated Civil Rights Act via Race-Conscious Admissions
Photo: Fox News
TL;DR

The Department of Justice and Department of Education concluded that UC Berkeley School of Law violated Title VI of the Civil Rights Act by favoring Black applicants over White and Asian peers. The agencies cited data showing Black applicants had 5.8 times higher odds of admission in 2025 and median LSAT scores approximately five points lower than their White and Asian counterparts. Berkeley Law denies the allegations, stating it complies with Proposition 209 and federal law by not considering race, while the DOJ seeks a voluntary compliance agreement.

Key points

  • DOJ and Dept. of Education found Berkeley Law in violation of Title VI for discriminating against White and Asian applicants.
  • Data shows Black applicants had 5.8x higher admission odds and lower median LSAT scores (165 vs. 172) than White/Asian admits.
  • Dean Erwin Chemerinsky is accused of encouraging staff to consider race in hiring/admissions despite public denials.
  • Berkeley Law rejects the findings, asserting its admissions process is race-neutral and compliant with Prop 209.
  • The DOJ is seeking a voluntary agreement to ensure legal compliance; litigation may follow if no agreement is reached.

Background

This action follows the Supreme Court’s 2023 ruling against affirmative action and California’s Proposition 209, which bans race-based preferences in public education. The DOJ launched a compliance review of Berkeley Law in March 2025 as part of a broader federal campaign targeting race-conscious admissions at elite universities, including recent findings against UCLA and UC San Diego medical schools.

How outlets are covering it

Fox News emphasizes the statistical disparities and the DOJ’s accusation that the school deliberately discriminated against White and Asian students. The Daily Californian highlights the specific allegation that Dean Erwin Chemerinsky encouraged staff to consider race in hiring despite public statements to the contrary, noting the school’s application questions about diversity. Inside Higher Ed frames the Berkeley finding as part of a simultaneous wave of federal actions against other institutions, such as Duke’s medical school, indicating a coordinated administrative strategy. Berkeley Law and UC administration counter these claims by stating that race is not a factor in admissions and that they are committed to merit-based selection, promising to provide evidence of compliance.

Why it matters

The finding sets a precedent for federal enforcement against 'race-neutral' diversity strategies that produce disparate outcomes. It signals that the Trump administration will aggressively pursue legal action against universities that fail to meet strict merit-based standards, potentially impacting admissions policies across the nation and influencing ongoing Title VI lawsuits regarding anti-Asian bias in higher education.

What to watch

The DOJ and Department of Education are seeking a voluntary agreement with UC Berkeley to bring admissions practices into legal compliance. If no agreement is reached, the agencies may pursue litigation. Berkeley Law has stated it will provide ample evidence to demonstrate its compliance with federal laws and Proposition 209.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on Fox News