Leapfall 2026: WNY hospitals split between top safety grades and mid-tier rankings

The Leapfrog Group’s fall 2026 Hospital Safety Grades show mixed results for Western New York, with two hospitals earning top marks and six receiving mid-tier scores. Nationally, the rankings highlight significant geographic disparities in patient safety, with some states having no top-rated facilities.
Key points
- Two Western New York hospitals, Mount St. Mary’s Hospital in Lewiston and United Memorial Medical Center in Batavia, received 'A' grades for patient safety.
- Six other regional hospitals, including Mercy Hospital of Buffalo and Buffalo General Medical Center, received 'C' grades, down from 'B' in the spring.
- The Leapfrog Group assigns grades based on up to 22 measures, including infection rates, surgical complications, and staffing levels.
- Nationally, 16% of hospitals were not graded due to lack of participation or data, while five states had no 'A' rated hospitals.
- Connecticut remains the top-ranked state, with 64.3% of its hospitals earning an 'A'.
Background
The Leapfrog Group releases hospital safety grades twice a year, using data from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services and its own survey. Previous coverage noted that Long Island hospitals also saw mixed results in this cycle, with some dropping in rank. The grades are intended to help patients evaluate facility safety, though experts caution that a single letter grade does not capture all aspects of care quality.
How outlets are covering it
Buffalo News focuses on the specific outcomes for Western New York hospitals, highlighting the drop in grades for several facilities. Newsweek provides a broader national context, emphasizing the geographic disparities and the fact that some states have no top-rated hospitals. Sarasota Herald-Tribune and Tampa Bay Times report on local successes in their respective regions, showing that some hospital systems maintained or improved their safety grades. The sources agree on the methodology but differ in their emphasis, with some highlighting regional successes and others focusing on areas of decline or lack of data.
Why it matters
These grades provide patients with a tool to evaluate hospital safety, but they also highlight the limitations of such rankings. The fact that some hospitals are not graded due to lack of participation or data means that the rankings do not cover all facilities. Additionally, the grades may not capture all aspects of care quality, and patients should consider multiple factors when choosing a hospital.
What to watch
The Leapfrog Group will release its next set of hospital safety grades in the spring of 2027. Patients can check their hospital's grade on the Leapfrog Group's website, which provides detailed information on various safety measures. Hospitals that received lower grades may implement changes to improve their safety performance in the next cycle.
- Six Western New York hospitals earn C grades in patient safety, others receive top marks Buffalo News
- 5 Sarasota-area hospitals earn top safety grades Sarasota Herald-Tribune
- Map Shows the Worst States to End up in Hospital: See How Yours Ranks Newsweek
- Tampa Bay-area BayCare hospitals earn top patient safety marks Tampa Bay Times
- Patient Safety Ratings Released for Area Hospitals Cape May County Herald
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on Buffalo News