Transcript reveals Cornell victim’s 2024 statement as DA reopens fraternity rape case

Key points

• The Tompkins County District Attorney is reopening the criminal case, sending the victim’s 2024 statement to a grand jury.
• CBS News obtained a transcript showing the victim, Jane Doe, told campus police in November 2024 that she was '100% confident' she was raped.
• The transcript indicates Jane Doe described drinking and using drugs, noting memory gaps, but distinguished initial consensual activity from later physical assault.
• Cornell University stated its Title IX investigation led to expulsions, suspensions, and the closure of the Chi Phi fraternity chapter.
• NBC News highlighted that New York state laws regarding consent and voluntary intoxication are under scrutiny for making it difficult for victims to seek criminal justice.

Background

In 2024, a former Cornell student alleged that members of the Chi Phi fraternity gang-raped her. The university conducted a Title IX investigation, resulting in sanctions for several individuals. The Tompkins County District Attorney initially declined to bring criminal charges, citing the victim’s 2024 statement. A civil lawsuit was also filed by the victim against the university and fraternity members. Governor Kathy Hochul previously called for a review of Cornell’s response to the incident.

How outlets are covering it

CBS News emphasized the content of the victim’s 2024 police interview, highlighting her confidence in her account despite memory gaps due to intoxication. Cornell University’s statement focused on the severity of its internal disciplinary actions, rejecting claims that consequences were minimal. NBC News framed the case within the broader context of New York’s stringent consent laws, noting that advocates have long criticized the state’s legal framework for hindering victims who voluntarily consumed alcohol or drugs. The Tompkins County DA’s office indicated the 2024 statement was central to the initial decision not to charge, prompting the current reopening of the investigation.

Why it matters

The reopening of the criminal case and the release of the victim’s 2024 statement could influence how New York handles sexual assault cases involving voluntary intoxication. It also tests the adequacy of university Title IX processes versus criminal justice outcomes in campus sexual violence cases.

What to watch

The Tompkins County District Attorney will present the case to a criminal grand jury. CBS News is awaiting responses from Jane Doe’s attorney and Cornell University. The outcome of the grand jury proceedings will determine whether criminal charges are filed against the accused fraternity members.