XX-XY Athletics and Christian Bookstore Challenge Colorado Pronoun Law in Federal Appeals

Jennifer Sey of XX-XY Athletics and the Smiths of Born Again Used Books are appealing a federal ruling that denied them protection from Colorado’s 2025 anti-discrimination law. They argue the statute compels businesses to use preferred pronouns, violating free speech. The state maintains the law only prohibits denial of service, not speech.
Key points
- The 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals heard arguments on Nov. 16, 2026, regarding the Kelly Loving Act (HB 25-1312), signed in May 2025.
- Plaintiffs argue the law forces them to use names and pronouns that conflict with their beliefs, risking fines up to $3,500 per violation or 120 days in jail.
- A federal judge in March 2026 denied a preliminary injunction, ruling the plaintiffs had not shown a credible threat of enforcement.
- In September 2026, the district court dismissed some advocacy groups but allowed the businesses and medical professionals to proceed.
- Colorado voters approved Proposition 134 in October 2026, requiring sports teams to be designated by biological sex, effective Jan. 1, 2027.
Background
This dispute follows a series of Supreme Court rulings against Colorado regarding compelled speech, including Masterpiece Cakeshop (2018) and 303 Creative (2023). Jennifer Sey, a former Levi Strauss executive, launched XX-XY Athletics in 2024 to advocate for women's sports based on biological sex. She recently led a successful campaign for Proposition 134, which passed with 52% support despite opposition spending nearly $4.5 million. The current lawsuit is part of a broader national trend of legal challenges to gender-identity protections in sports and public accommodations.
How outlets are covering it
OutKick emphasizes Sey's distrust of the state, quoting her 'trust me, bro' defense, and highlights the potential for criminal penalties. The Colorado Springs Gazette focuses on the religious freedom aspect, with the Smiths arguing the law outlaws their biblical worldview. Law Commentary notes the legal distinction between compelled speech and denial of service, highlighting the state's argument that the law does not change substantive rights. All sources agree that the core conflict is between anti-discrimination protections and First Amendment claims regarding compelled language.
Why it matters
The outcome will determine whether businesses can be penalized for using language that contradicts a customer's gender identity. It tests the limits of anti-discrimination laws in the context of free speech and religious expression, potentially setting a precedent for similar challenges in other states.
What to watch
The 10th Circuit panel has taken the case under consideration but has not announced a ruling date. Governor-elect Phil Weiser has suggested he may review Proposition 134, which Sey has vowed to defend. The case will likely influence how other states interpret anti-discrimination laws regarding gender expression.
- Jennifer Sey fights Colorado law that could punish businesses for refusing transgender pronouns Fox News
- Court weighs lawsuit over Colorado’s transgender pronouns law Colorado Politics
- Appeals Court grapples with Colorado antidiscrimination law requiring preferred pronouns Washington Examiner
- Colorado Pronoun Law Faces First Amendment Challenge in Federal Court Law Commentary
- GUEST OPINION: Springs bookstore challenges law that limits freedom Colorado Springs Gazette
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on Fox News