Cassidy blocks O’Neill’s NSF nomination over CDC record

3 min read
Source: STAT
Cassidy blocks O’Neill’s NSF nomination over CDC record
Photo: STAT
TL;DR

Senate Health Committee Chair Bill Cassidy canceled a confirmation vote for Jim O’Neill to lead the National Science Foundation, citing his failure to defend scientific integrity during his tenure at the CDC and HHS. O’Neill, who served as acting CDC director and HHS deputy secretary under Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., would have led the NSF for six years if confirmed. Cassidy stated O’Neill lacked the support to advance and did not stand up against 'irresponsible decisions' from Kennedy. The move ends O’Neill’s bid before a Democratic-led Senate takes control in January, leaving the NSF under interim leadership.

Key points

  • Cassidy canceled the vote, stating O’Neill 'did not do enough to stand up for science and against irresponsible decisions and statements' from Kennedy.
  • O’Neill served as acting CDC director from August 2025 to February 2026 and HHS deputy secretary from June 2025 to February 2026.
  • Cassidy cited O’Neill’s role in the firing of CDC director Susan Monarez in 2025 as a concern for his independent judgment.
  • The NSF has been without a Senate-confirmed leader since April 2025, when Sethuraman Panchanathan resigned amid grant cancellations and funding cuts.
  • The White House withdrew the nomination of Heidi Overton for FDA commissioner before Cassidy’s vote, citing a lack of support.

Background

The NSF has faced significant budget cuts and grant freezes under the Trump administration. In April 2025, Trump removed every member of the National Science Board, the agency’s presidentially appointed oversight body. Cassidy, a physician, lost his primary earlier this year to a Trump-backed challenger and has faced criticism from public health leaders for confirming Kennedy. The White House withdrew Heidi Overton’s nomination for FDA commissioner before Cassidy’s vote, citing a lack of support, despite Cassidy’s statement that she would have had the votes.

How outlets are covering it

STAT and The Hill reported that Cassidy canceled the vote, stating O’Neill lacked the support to advance and did not stand up for science. The Guardian emphasized that O’Neill’s run ended before a Democratic-led Senate took control in January, noting the White House did not pull his nomination. Politico highlighted Cassidy’s statement that O’Neill 'did not do enough to stand up for science' and the White House’s withdrawal of Heidi Overton’s nomination. All sources agreed that Cassidy cited O’Neill’s failure to defend scientific integrity during his tenure at the CDC and HHS as the reason for canceling the vote.

Why it matters

The cancellation of O’Neill’s nomination leaves the NSF without a Senate-confirmed leader, potentially impacting the agency’s ability to fund basic research and manage its budget. The move also highlights the ongoing tensions between the Trump administration and Senate Republicans over scientific integrity and public health policies. The NSF’s leadership vacuum may have long-term consequences for the agency’s mission and the broader scientific community.

What to watch

The White House may nominate a new candidate to lead the NSF, though the timing and selection remain uncertain. The Democratic-led Senate, which takes control in January, may prioritize confirming a new NSF director or addressing the agency’s budget and grant issues. The White House’s withdrawal of Heidi Overton’s nomination for FDA commissioner may also influence future nominations and confirmations in the health sector.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on STAT