Cornyn blocks Gaiser judicial pick, confirming floor clash with Cruz

Outgoing Texas Senator John Cornyn has blocked President Trump’s nomination of T. Elliot Gaiser for a federal judgeship in the Northern District of Texas by withholding his 'blue slip.' Cornyn, who is leaving office after losing the primary to Ken Paxton, objected to Gaiser’s lack of Texas residency and trial experience. The dispute escalated into a public shouting match on the Senate floor, which Cruz confirmed involved Cornyn cursing at him. While Cruz argues the block hands the seat to Democrats, Cornyn insists he offered an alternative candidate and that the White House ignored the Senate’s constitutional role.
Key points
- Cornyn withheld his blue slip, blocking Gaiser’s nomination for the Northern District of Texas.
- Cruz confirmed Cornyn shouted and cursed at him on the Senate floor during a dispute.
- Cornyn argued Gaiser is not from Texas and lacks trial experience, violating 'advice and consent.'
- Cruz stated the White House chose Gaiser because his background check was already complete.
- Cornyn recommended Steve Fahey as an alternative candidate for the vacant seat.
- Trump called Cornyn’s action a 'tremendous disservice' and blamed his primary loss for the anger.
Background
This dispute occurs as Republicans attempt to confirm judicial nominees before Democrats take control of the Senate in January. The seat in the Northern District of Texas has been vacant since 2025. Cornyn lost the Republican primary to Ken Paxton, who subsequently lost to Democrat James Talarico. Previous coverage highlighted tensions over Gaiser’s controversial legal opinions, including those regarding lethal strikes and abortion medication restrictions.
How outlets are covering it
Cruz and the White House view the block as political obstruction that will leave the seat vacant for Democrats. Fox News emphasized Trump’s criticism of Cornyn, while CBS News focused on the confirmed verbal altercation. The Guardian and CNN highlighted Cornyn’s argument that the nomination lacked proper consultation and that he offered a vetted alternative. CNN noted Gaiser’s controversial OLC opinions, whereas Fox News framed the issue as a partisan fight over the lame-duck session.
Why it matters
The block prevents a final judicial appointment before the change in Senate leadership, potentially leaving the Northern District of Texas without a judge for an extended period. It highlights deep rifts within the Republican Party and the effectiveness of the 'blue slip' tradition in blocking presidential nominees.
What to watch
The seat will likely remain vacant as Democrats assume control of the Senate in January. Cornyn has stated he is willing to work with the White House if they accept his alternative candidate, Steve Fahey, but the White House has not indicated it will do so.
- Cruz confirms report that Cornyn shouted and cursed at him on the Senate floor CBS News
- John Cornyn blocks Trump judicial nominee after Senate shouting match with Ted Cruz The Guardian
- Sen. Cornyn blocks judicial nominee because Trump didn’t choose Texas CNN
- Trump says Sen Cornyn is doing a 'tremendous disservice' by blocking Texas judicial pick Fox News
- Cornyn blocks Trump’s nomination to federal district court because he didn’t choose a Texan The Hill
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on CBS News