DOJ drops Alaska Senate lawsuit as Peltola’s majority win renders vote-count dispute moot

The U.S. Department of Justice has withdrawn its lawsuit seeking to block the certification of Alaska’s 2026 U.S. Senate election results, declaring the case moot after Democrat Mary Peltola secured a decisive victory. Peltola won more than 50% of the vote, a margin that ensures her win even if all ballots cast for a similarly named candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., were counted for incumbent Republican Dan S. Sullivan. The DOJ had previously sued to delay certification pending an investigation into alleged voter confusion. While the lawsuit is dropped, federal and state investigations into the Peltola campaign and the recruitment of the spoiler candidate continue.
Key points
- DOJ filed a motion on Nov. 19 to dismiss its lawsuit, stating it is impossible to determine voter intent because ballots for the two Sullivans were commingled.
- Peltola won 50.3% of first-choice votes in Alaska’s ranked-choice system, compared to 45.9% for Dan S. Sullivan and 1.7% for Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.
- The DOJ’s criminal investigation has shifted focus from the spoiler candidate to the Peltola campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee.
- Alaska Governor Mike Dunleavy refused to confirm Peltola will take office, citing ongoing investigations, though state certification is expected by Nov. 25.
- Peltola’s victory gives Democrats a 56-seat majority in the Senate, the largest since 2011.
Background
The DOJ initially sued in October to block certification, arguing that voter confusion between Dan S. Sullivan and Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. could taint a narrow Democratic victory. A federal judge dismissed the suit before the election, ruling that segregating votes would violate secret ballot rights. The DOJ appealed to the Ninth Circuit but later conceded the case was moot after Peltola’s majority win. This follows a similar DOJ withdrawal in California regarding noncitizen ballot claims.
How outlets are covering it
USA TODAY and CNN emphasize that the legal challenge is over because Peltola’s margin exceeds the votes for the spoiler candidate, making the outcome unambiguous. However, CNN and Democracy Docket highlight that the DOJ’s criminal probe continues, now targeting the Peltola campaign and Democratic operatives for allegedly recruiting the spoiler. Governor Dunleavy, per Democracy Docket, maintains that investigations may support a challenge by Sen. Sullivan, despite acknowledging the vote gap. Yahoo focuses on the broader political impact, noting the win secures a historic Democratic majority in the Senate and House, shifting focus to legislative priorities and potential impeachments.
Why it matters
The dismissal ends a federal legal attempt to block a state election result, reinforcing the principle that a clear majority vote cannot be overturned by post-election litigation. However, the ongoing criminal investigation into the Peltola campaign and the governor’s equivocation on certification create uncertainty regarding Peltola’s seating in January and the stability of the new Democratic Senate majority.
What to watch
Alaska officials are expected to certify Peltola’s win by Nov. 25. Sen. Dan Sullivan has until Dec. 5 to contest the result. The DOJ will continue its criminal investigation into the Peltola campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee. Democrats will finalize their Senate leadership, with Chuck Schumer and Chris Van Hollen competing for majority leader, and the House will elect Hakeem Jeffries as speaker.
- Justice Department drops lawsuit over Alaska Senate election USA Today
- Alaska governor won’t give up on long-shot bid to subvert Democratic Senate win Democracy Docket
- Final 2026 midterm election results: Democrats clinch 56-seat Senate majority with Peltola's Alaska win. What they can — and can't — do next. Yahoo
- DOJ Alaska Senate race investigation shifts focus toward Peltola campaign and Democratic operatives CNN
- Commentary: Will Alaska’s blue wave become a blue waste? Alaska Beacon
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on USA Today