Judge Halts DOJ Threats to Washington Election Officials Over Noncitizen Ballot Demands

4 min read
Source: Politico
TL;DR

A federal judge in Seattle issued a temporary restraining order prohibiting the Justice Department from demanding that Washington state set aside ballots of individuals suspected of being noncitizens. The order follows a lawsuit by voter advocacy and labor groups alleging the federal government is engaging in voter intimidation. While the DOJ claims to have identified over 400 potential noncitizen voters, state officials and plaintiffs argue the data is flawed and the actions aim to suppress turnout ahead of the midterms.

Key points

  • U.S. District Judge Jamal Whitehead issued a temporary restraining order on Thursday, barring the DOJ from threatening election officials or demanding the exclusion of ballots based on a federal list for two weeks.
  • The lawsuit was filed by OneAmerica Votes, the United Food and Commercial Workers 3000, and the Latino Community Fund of Washington, accusing the administration of violating constitutional voting rights.
  • The dispute centers on a list of approximately 400 voters sent to Washington Secretary of State Steve Hobbs on October 26, which federal prosecutors claimed contained suspected noncitizens who voted in past elections.
  • Hobbs rejected the federal list as unreliable, noting that it included U.S. citizens and individuals with cancelled registrations, and stated that counting ballots based on unverified data would likely be unlawful.
  • Plaintiffs' attorney Abha Khanna described the federal matching process as baseless and the list as a tool for intimidation rather than evidence of illegal voting.

Background

This conflict occurs amid a broader national push by the Trump administration to enforce noncitizen voting laws, a strategy recently challenged by a federal judge in Florida who ruled the relevant statute unconstitutional. Earlier in October, Chief Judge James Boasberg ordered the administration to disclose all states targeted with similar demands to alter election administration. State officials have also been coordinating to counter perceived federal interference, including reduced support from the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, as they prepare for the 2026 midterm elections.

How outlets are covering it

The Justice Department maintains that the list identifies suspected noncitizens who illegally voted in previous elections and that their ballots should not be counted until citizenship is verified. In contrast, plaintiffs and Washington state officials argue the list is 'faulty, over-inclusive' and lacks evidentiary value. KUOW reports that the lawsuit characterizes the federal actions as an attempt to create a 'non-problem' to disenfranchise lawful voters and suppress turnout. KOMO highlights Hobbs’s public stance that the federal findings are 'greatly exaggerated or false,' emphasizing that his office will continue to count all incoming ballots. While the DOJ views the list as a security measure, critics, including Roxana Norouzi of OneAmerica Votes, frame it as part of an authoritarian agenda to keep immigrant communities in a state of fear and deny election results they oppose.

Why it matters

The ruling sets a precedent for state-level resistance to federal demands regarding ballot counting during the 2026 midterms. It highlights the escalating legal battles over voter eligibility and the tension between federal enforcement efforts and state election administration. The temporary restraining order provides a brief window for Washington to certify results without federal interference, potentially influencing the outcome of close races and shaping future litigation regarding the constitutionality of noncitizen voting enforcement.

What to watch

The temporary restraining order is set to last for two weeks, covering the period during which Washington counties count and certify ballots. No hearing date has been set for the broader lawsuit seeking a permanent injunction. The Justice Department may appeal the ruling or continue to press for the exclusion of the listed voters, while state officials will monitor for further federal attempts to interfere with the certification process. The outcome of this case could influence similar disputes in other states, such as California, which has already refused similar federal demands.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on Politico