Mississippi Senate race hinges on thousands of affidavit ballots after Experian data errors

3 min read
Source: Mississippi Today
Mississippi Senate race hinges on thousands of affidavit ballots after Experian data errors
Photo: Mississippi Today
TL;DR

Mississippi's U.S. Senate race between Democrat Scott Colom and Republican Cindy Hyde-Smith remains unresolved due to a surge in inactive voter registrations. Over 230,000 voters were marked inactive before the midterms, largely attributed to errors in unverified address data from Experian, a credit bureau. Civil rights groups warned Secretary of State Michael Watson days before the election to reinstate these voters, but his office did not respond. Many voters were forced to cast affidavit ballots, delaying the count and raising questions about the reliability of commercial data in voter roll maintenance.

Key points

  • Colom leads Hyde-Smith by approximately 2,000 votes as of Friday, but the margin is within the range of outstanding affidavit and mail ballots.
  • Over 230,000 Mississippians were listed as inactive before the midterms, up from roughly 166,000 in 2024.
  • A coalition including the ACLU and NAACP Legal Defense Fund sent Watson a letter four days before the election demanding the reinstatement of voters inactivated by Experian data; the office did not respond.
  • Watson’s office signed a $50,000 contract with Experian in 2024, despite disclaimers that the data could not guarantee accuracy or reliability.
  • Voters like Thomas Minor and Kailyn Lott were mistakenly inactivated due to incorrect address data, with some unable to vote or required to use affidavit ballots.
  • The state has since switched to IDI Data, but voting rights groups argue the prior errors indicate systemic issues with commercial data brokers.

Background

Mississippi’s use of Experian data began in 2024 as a pilot in Lafayette County, which Watson called a success. However, Mississippi Today reported in March 2026 that errors in the data led to wrongful inactivations. The state expanded the use of Experian data to all 82 counties, replacing government sources like the U.S. Postal Service. This shift occurred amid a broader national scrutiny of voter roll maintenance practices.

How outlets are covering it

Mississippi Today and civil rights groups emphasize that Watson’s office ignored warnings and failed to reinstate voters, attributing the errors to unverified Experian data. Watson’s office, via Assistant Secretary Liz Jonson, dismissed the coalition’s demands, stating that third parties cannot dictate election laws and that the system was in a blackout period. Axios and Scripps News highlight the uncertainty in the Senate race and the impact on voter confidence, while noting Experian’s statement that it has not provided services to the state since early 2025. Democracy Docket focuses on the procedural aspects of curing affidavit ballots, noting that most are being counted without additional steps, but some voters face issues due to precinct changes or lack of ID. Watson defended the process as a 'safety net' for election integrity, while critics argue it disenfranchised eligible voters.

Why it matters

The outcome of the Mississippi Senate race could be decided by a handful of ballots, with the delay in counting raising questions about the reliability of commercial data in voter roll maintenance. The incident has drawn national attention to the potential for disenfranchisement through unverified data and has prompted calls for reforms in election administration. It also highlights the tension between election integrity and voter access, with implications for future elections and the use of third-party data in voter roll maintenance.

What to watch

Counties must certify results by Nov. 13, with a cure period for affidavit ballots ending Nov. 10. The Colom and Hyde-Smith campaigns are preparing for a legal battle over the vote count. Watson’s office has not responded to questions about when or why it ended the Experian partnership. Voting rights groups are advocating for changes to the system to prevent similar errors in the future.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on Mississippi Today