NYC Horse Carriage Ban Signed Into Law, Prompting Immediate Federal Lawsuit

4 min read
Source: NBC New York
NYC Horse Carriage Ban Signed Into Law, Prompting Immediate Federal Lawsuit
Photo: NBC New York
TL;DR

Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed 'Romanch's Law' into effect on November 19, 2026, banning horse-drawn carriages in New York City by June 1, 2028. The legislation, named after 18-year-old Romanch Mahajan who died in a June carriage accident, ends a 150-year tradition. Minutes after the signing, the Transport Workers Union filed a federal lawsuit challenging the ban as unconstitutional, arguing it destroys property values without guaranteed compensation. The city plans to support approximately 200 affected workers through medallion buybacks and job training, with a full transition plan due by April 2027.

Key points

  • Mayor Mamdani signed the ban into law on November 19, 2026, setting a June 1, 2028 deadline for the end of horse-drawn carriage operations.
  • The Transport Workers Union filed a federal lawsuit in Manhattan minutes after the signing, alleging the city is taking property without due process or guaranteed compensation.
  • The law requires the city to develop a transition plan by April 2027, including medallion buybacks and workforce development for approximately 200 affected workers.
  • The ban was passed by the City Council in October following the death of Romanch Mahajan, an 18-year-old tourist who died in a June carriage accident in Central Park.
  • The city is commissioning a feasibility study to explore electric carriages and pedal-assist bicycles as potential replacements in Central Park.

Background

The ban follows a decades-long debate over animal welfare and public safety in Central Park. The New York City Council passed the measure in October 2026 by a 40-7 vote, overriding previous mayoral efforts to ban the industry. The legislation is named after Romanch Mahajan, who died in June 2026 after a horse bolted during a family photo session. Previous attempts by mayors Bill de Blasio and others to ban the industry had failed, but the fatal accident accelerated the legislative process. The city has previously implemented safety regulations, including veterinary checkups and retirement ages for horses, but animal welfare activists argued these measures were insufficient.

How outlets are covering it

Supporters, including Council Speaker Julie Menin and animal welfare groups, argue the ban is necessary to protect public safety and animal welfare, citing the fatal accident and decades of advocacy. The Transport Workers Union, represented by attorney Arthur Schwartz, contends the law is unconstitutional, claiming it destroys the value of medallions purchased for $300,000-$400,000 without guaranteed compensation. The union argues the city is ignoring property rights and contracts. The New York Times notes that the law requires the city to consider compensation but does not mandate it, creating uncertainty for workers. The Central Park Conservancy criticized the proposed electric carriage alternatives, while the city's law department is reviewing the lawsuit. The perspectives highlight a conflict between public safety/animal welfare and property rights/worker compensation.

Why it matters

The ban ends a 150-year tradition in New York City and sets a precedent for how the city handles the phaseout of traditional industries. The immediate legal challenge tests the constitutionality of the city's approach to compensating affected workers and protecting property rights. The outcome will influence future policies on urban transportation and animal welfare, and the transition plan will determine how the city supports approximately 200 workers in finding new livelihoods. The case also raises questions about the city's responsibility to compensate workers for the loss of property value and the adequacy of transition plans in similar cases.

What to watch

The Transport Workers Union's federal lawsuit will proceed in the Southern District of New York, with the city's law department reviewing the case. The city is required to release a full transition plan by April 2027, including details on medallion buybacks and workforce development. The feasibility study on electric carriages and pedal-assist bicycles will be completed, and the city will determine whether to implement these alternatives in Central Park. The ban takes full effect on June 1, 2028, at which point horse-drawn carriages will no longer operate on city streets.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on NBC New York