Trump’s APEC Dozing Sparks Debate Over Presidential Health and Media Scrutiny

3 min read
Source: The Guardian
Trump’s APEC Dozing Sparks Debate Over Presidential Health and Media Scrutiny
Photo: The Guardian
TL;DR

Donald Trump was accused of falling asleep during Xi Jinping’s speech at the APEC summit in Shenzhen. The White House denied the claim, stating he was reviewing documents. Critics and allies debated the incident, with some dismissing it as blinking and others highlighting the optics of the moment during a high-stakes diplomatic visit.

Key points

  • Trump appeared to close his eyes for about 10 seconds while Xi spoke at the APEC summit in Shenzhen.
  • White House communications director Steven Cheung called the claims 'fake news,' asserting Trump was looking at papers.
  • Critics, including Republicans Against Trump and Gavin Newsom’s office, alleged the president was asleep.
  • Slate noted that major outlets like the NYT and WSJ did not cover the incident, contrasting it with past scrutiny of Biden’s health.
  • The New Republic listed multiple recent instances of Trump dozing at public events, raising concerns about his health.

Background

This incident occurred during a high-profile diplomatic trip to Asia, where Trump met with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin. Previous archive coverage noted that the APEC summit in Shenzhen was a key moment for US-China relations, with Xi urging Washington to handle the Taiwan issue correctly. The summit also featured a historic trilateral meeting with Putin, highlighting Beijing’s diplomatic balancing act. Trump’s age and health have been subjects of ongoing scrutiny, with previous reports noting his status as the oldest US president and his claims of perfect cognitive health.

How outlets are covering it

The Guardian and The Independent reported the incident neutrally, noting the White House denial and the criticism from political opponents. Slate emphasized the lack of media coverage compared to past scrutiny of Biden’s health, arguing that the incident should have drawn more attention. The New Republic took a more critical stance, listing multiple instances of Trump dozing and expressing concern about his health, while also mocking the White House’s denial. The sources generally agreed on the facts of the incident but differed in their interpretation of its significance and the media’s response.

Why it matters

The incident raises questions about the health and fitness of an 80-year-old president, particularly during a high-stakes diplomatic visit. It also highlights the media’s selective scrutiny of presidential health, with Slate noting a disparity in coverage compared to past scrutiny of Biden. The White House’s denial and the criticism from political opponents underscore the ongoing debate over Trump’s fitness for office.

What to watch

The incident is unlikely to have immediate policy implications, but it may continue to fuel debates about Trump’s health and the media’s role in scrutinizing presidential fitness. The White House is expected to continue denying the claims, while critics may use the incident to question Trump’s ability to handle the demands of the presidency.

Share this article

Want the full story? Read the original reporting

Read on The Guardian