Browns retain Watson for Carolina opener despite mixed reception

Key points

• Todd Monken confirmed Deshaun Watson will start against the Panthers, citing the quarterback's effort in the recent win over Tampa Bay.
• Watson completed 24 of 30 passes for 238 yards and two touchdowns in the 23-19 victory over the Buccaneers, a performance described as sufficient to retain his job.
• The Browns face a demanding schedule, playing the Panthers on Sunday and the Pittsburgh Steelers the following Thursday, raising concerns about Watson's consistency.
• NBC Sports notes that Cleveland fans may be vocal if Watson struggles in the upcoming games, given the team's recent history.
• The decision comes after Watson's poor performance in the Week 1 loss to Jacksonville, where he threw an interception and fumbled.

Background

Watson's return to the starting lineup has been contentious since his injury absence. In Week 1, the Browns lost 34-10 to the Jacksonville Jaguars, with Watson struggling significantly, leading to fan calls for backup Shedeur Sanders. Preseason reports indicated an open competition between Watson and Sanders, with Monken planning to split duties. The current decision to stick with Watson for the home opener reflects a continued attempt to give the veteran quarterback a chance to stabilize the offense, despite previous failures.

How outlets are covering it

NBC Sports reports that Monken is sticking with Watson based on his recent performance against Tampa Bay, emphasizing the coach's satisfaction with Watson's effort. In contrast, The New York Times (via The Athletic) criticizes the decision, arguing that Watson is no longer a viable starter and that the Browns are unfairly burdening other players and coaches with his deficiencies. The NYT piece highlights Watson's poor Week 1 performance and questions the logic of continuing to use him, especially after a 34-10 loss to Jacksonville. While NBC focuses on the immediate decision and Monken's stance, The NYT provides a broader critique of the franchise's handling of the Watson situation, suggesting that the team should consider replacing him to avoid further damage.

Why it matters

The decision to retain Watson for the home opener is significant as it tests the Browns' commitment to their veteran quarterback despite recent struggles. It impacts the team's short-term performance and long-term strategy, particularly with a challenging schedule ahead. The outcome of the next games will likely determine whether Watson remains the starter or if the team shifts to Shedeur Sanders or another option, affecting the team's overall trajectory and fan sentiment.

What to watch

The Browns will face the Carolina Panthers in their Week 3 home opener, followed by a Thursday night game against the Pittsburgh Steelers. The performance of Watson in these games will be crucial in determining his future with the team. If Watson struggles, the Browns may consider benching him in favor of Shedeur Sanders or another quarterback. The outcome of these games will also influence fan sentiment and the team's overall strategy for the remainder of the season.