Tuchel's gamble leaves England grappling with World Cup blueprint after Argentina defeat

England’s World Cup semi-final loss to Argentina has sparked a wide-ranging debate over Thomas Tuchel’s tactical switch to a back five, his defence rotation, and England’s midfield choices. Pundits question whether sticking with a back four might have preserved the lead and why key selections, including Kobbie Mainoo’s absence, were made. The FA have reiterated their backing of Tuchel through Euro 2028, while Kane’s form and future are scrutinised as England head into the bronze-medal clash with France and seek a more assertive, stable approach for 2028 and beyond.