1965 Pyrex Pumpkin Butterprint Cinderella Bowls Command Premium Prices
A 1965 Pyrex pattern known as Pumpkin Butterprint, also called Amish Butterprint, has become a sought-after item in the vintage dish market. Produced in limited promotional sets of four, these orange-on-white or turquoise Cinderella bowls feature harvest-themed illustrations and can sell for hundreds of dollars online. Collectors are advised to watch thrift stores for these items, as the Cinderella shape was discontinued in the early 1980s, making any surviving examples likely authentic vintage pieces.
Key points
- The Pumpkin Butterprint pattern was introduced in 1965 and is also known as Amish Butterprint due to its depictions of behatted figures in harvest scenes.
- The pattern was produced in limited quantities as part of a promotional set of four, making it inherently collectible from its inception.
- Most surviving examples feature orange patterns on white backgrounds, though turquoise versions were also manufactured.
- The pattern was exclusively produced in the Cinderella bowl style, which features extended lips for handling and pouring, and was discontinued in the early 1980s.
- Current online listings for these dishes can reach hundreds of dollars, making thrift store discoveries potentially valuable.
Background
This story follows a trend of rare vintage kitchenware surfacing in secondhand markets, similar to the 1950s Black Tulip Pyrex casserole and 1995 Le Creuset Duck Dutch Oven noted in previous coverage. While those items also command premium prices, the Pumpkin Butterprint is distinguished by its specific 1965 promotional origin and exclusive Cinderella shape.
Why it matters
The story highlights how limited promotional runs and discontinued shapes can transform ordinary kitchen items into valuable collectibles, encouraging consumers to inspect vintage dishware more carefully for specific patterns and manufacturing details.
What to watch
Collectors and thrift shoppers are likely to continue scanning secondhand stores for Pumpkin Butterprint Cinderella bowls, potentially driving up prices as supply remains limited and demand from vintage kitchenware enthusiasts persists.
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on Chowhound