Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ Faces Backlash Over Undisclosed AI Music in GTA-Themed Mode

Nicalis removed AI-generated music from The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ after players discovered Suno metadata in a new GTA-themed mode. Creator Edmund McMillen stated he was unaware of the inclusion, and the game’s Steam rating dropped to 8% positive due to the undisclosed content and pre-existing quality issues.
Key points
- A Reddit user identified 14 music files in the new 'V1CE BSMT' daily run, finding 'made with Suno' metadata in several tracks.
- Nicalis issued a patch to remove the AI-generated music from the PC version, but console players are still waiting for the update.
- Edmund McMillen admitted he did not know about the AI music and is investigating how it entered the release build.
- The controversy contributed to a sharp drop in Steam reviews, with recent ratings falling to 8% positive.
- Valve requires AI disclosure on Steam, but Repentance+ lacked this notice despite the new content.
Background
The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ launched on consoles this week, coinciding with the release of Grand Theft Auto 6. The update added online co-op and a special crime-themed daily run. This incident follows broader industry discussions about AI-generated content, such as recent studies showing AI assistance in academic papers and debates over AI in music awards.
How outlets are covering it
GoNintendo reported the discovery and McMillen's response. Kotaku highlighted the review-bombing and blamed Nicalis for quality control issues. Superpower Daily emphasized the lack of disclosure and the pending console patch. All sources agree on the removal of the music but differ on the extent of Nicalis's responsibility for the underlying quality issues.
Why it matters
This incident highlights growing player sensitivity to undisclosed AI content in games and the importance of transparency in game development. It also raises questions about quality control in major indie titles and the impact of such controversies on a beloved franchise's reputation.
What to watch
Nicalis must release the patch for console platforms. The studio may need to address ongoing bugs and quality issues to restore player confidence. McMillen will continue investigating how the AI music was included in the release.
- The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ Online mode appears to contain AI generated music, creator working on getting it removed GoNintendo
- Edmund McMillen Discusses The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ Cubed3
- Binding Of Isaac Update Review-Bombed Over AI-Generated Music In GTA 6 Mode: 'Woke Up To A Sh*t Show, Obviously I Had No Idea' Kotaku
- Nicalis removes AI music from The Binding of Isaac after player backlash Superpower Daily
- The Binding of Isaac add-on receives “overwhelmingly negative” reviews on Steam — players are unhappy with the quality of co-op iXBT.games
Want the full story? Read the original reporting
Read on GoNintendo